Re-read War Photographer and Prayer Before Birth in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present the suffering of innocent people in War Photographer and Prayer Before Birth.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Both Duffy and MacNeice present the suffering that human cruelty inflicts on the innocent, and both criticise a world that allows it. However, Duffy presents suffering that has already happened, seen through the camera of a photographer who must control his feelings, while MacNeice presents suffering that is feared, in the voice of an unborn child who has no control at all.
The two poems give the innocent very different voices. In War Photographer the victims are silent: they exist only as images on film, the "spools of suffering" that the photographer develops in his darkroom. The alliteration of the soft 's' sounds makes the phrase quiet and solemn, while the metaphor turns rolls of film into containers of pain. In Prayer Before Birth the innocent victim speaks for himself. The refrain "I am not yet born" opens stanza after stanza, stressing his helplessness and purity: he has not yet done anything, yet he already fears what the world will do to him. Duffy's victims cannot speak; MacNeice's speaker can do nothing but speak.
Both poets show the causes of suffering. Duffy lists war zones, Belfast, Beirut and Phnom Penh, places of conflict in different parts of the world, so suffering seems universal, and a biblical reference to the shortness of human life adds a sense of tragedy. In the third stanza a stranger's face slowly appears in the developing tray, and the photographer remembers how the dying man's wife cried out. MacNeice instead imagines the horrors in advance: nightmarish creatures, and then human cruelties such as imprisonment, drugs, lies and torture, piled up in long lists with internal rhyme and alliteration that make them sound relentless. Above all, the child fears being made into "a cog in a machine", losing his individuality and becoming a tool of war or of the state. The poem was written in 1944, during the Second World War, when such fears were very real.
The poets also criticise those who allow suffering to continue. Duffy's photographer knows that, of "a hundred agonies" captured on his film, his editor will choose only a few for a Sunday supplement, and that readers will feel a moment of pity before carrying on with their comfortable weekend. The contrast between the war zones and peaceful England exposes their indifference, and in the final lines the photographer looks without expression at a country that does not care. MacNeice's child asks to be forgiven for the sins that others will commit through him, which suggests that innocent people are forced to take part in the world's violence. Both poets therefore blame not only those who cause suffering but also the society that tolerates it.
Religious language appears in both poems. Duffy's photographer works under the red light of his darkroom like a priest preparing to say Mass, so his work becomes a solemn ritual of respect for the dead. MacNeice's whole poem is a prayer, addressed to a higher power with a series of requests to hear, console, protect and forgive. In neither poem, however, does religion bring comfort: the photographer's ritual cannot save the dead, and the child's prayer ends with a stark ultimatum.
The forms reflect the different situations. War Photographer has four six-line stanzas with a regular rhyme scheme, like the neat rows of film in the darkroom, and this control mirrors the professional detachment the photographer needs in order to do his job; the emotion is held in, and it is all the more powerful for that. Prayer Before Birth uses irregular stanzas that mostly grow longer as the fears accumulate, so the shape of the poem swells with panic, until the short final stanza breaks the pattern of the refrain and ends abruptly. Duffy's form contains suffering; MacNeice's overflows with it.
In conclusion, both poems present the suffering of the innocent as the result of human cruelty and indifference. Duffy shows it through silent images and a controlled, regular form that reflects the photographer's restraint, while MacNeice gives the innocent a desperate voice and a form that expands with fear. Together they suggest that the world's suffering demands a response that most people fail to give.