Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/26

Comparing anthology poems

Practise 24 exam-style questions on Comparing anthology poems for Edexcel International GCSE English Literature (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 24 questions
  • 1–30 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

In which poem does the speaker ask a series of questions addressed to an animal?

Choose your answer.

  • La Belle Dame sans Merci
  • Blessing
  • The Tyger
  • Prayer Before Birth

Model answer

The Tyger (every stanza questions the tiger about who made it).

Explanation

Questions are a key structural feature of The Tyger: they are never answered, which creates a sense of awe and mystery. This makes the poem a good partner for other poems that address a listener, such as La Belle Dame sans Merci (questions to a knight) or Prayer Before Birth (requests to a higher power).

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    The Tyger

    If more than one option is given, 0 marks. The Tyger is built almost entirely of questions addressed to the tiger, such as "What immortal hand or eye, / Could frame thy fearful symmetry?" In La Belle Dame sans Merci the questions are addressed to a knight, not an animal; Prayer Before Birth is a prayer of requests addressed to a higher power; Blessing describes a scene rather than questioning an animal.

Question 2

4 marks

Explain two ways in which the writers present an adult teaching a child in Half-past Two and Poem at Thirty-Nine. Give one way from each poem.

Model answer

In Half-past Two, the teacher's words are capitalised, as in "Something Very Wrong", which shows how huge and mysterious adult authority seems to the boy; ironically, the teacher then forgets him, and he learns something she never intended in "the clockless land". In Poem at Thirty-Nine, the father's teaching is practical and moral: he showed his daughter how to write cheques and that "telling the truth" did not always lead to a beating. These lessons live on in the adult speaker's habits, so remembering what he taught her becomes a way of mourning and loving him.

Explanation

This question asks for one method from each poem and an explanation of each. Choose a precise detail, such as the capital letters in Half-past Two or the father's lessons in Poem at Thirty-Nine, and explain what it shows about the relationship between adult and child. Avoid describing the poems in general terms without evidence.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Half-past Two: a valid way, e.g. the teacher's words are given capital letters ("Something Very Wrong") to show how huge and mysterious adult authority seems to the child // the teacher sets a time that the boy cannot read and then forgets him // the boy learns something the teacher never intended, in "the clockless land"

    Accept a close reference instead of a quotation.

  2. 1 mark

    ...explains the effect of the Half-past Two example, e.g. the capitals show that the boy feels the importance of his crime without understanding it // the teacher's forgetfulness is gently humorous and makes the adult seem careless // the real lesson is about timelessness, not telling the time

    Only awarded if the first mark is awarded.

  3. 1 mark

    Poem at Thirty-Nine: a valid way, e.g. the father taught practical skills such as writing cheques and keeping accounts // he taught moral lessons, such as that "telling the truth" did not always lead to a beating // he loved to cook, and the speaker now cooks as he did

    Accept a close reference instead of a quotation.

  4. 1 mark

    ...explains the effect of the Poem at Thirty-Nine example, e.g. the lessons live on in the adult speaker's habits, so remembering them becomes a way of mourning and loving him // she realises how like him she has become // the honest detail about beatings shows a complex, imperfect relationship

    max 4. Only awarded if the third mark is awarded.

Question 3

12 marks

Compare how the writers present the power of the past in Piano and Search For My Tongue.

You should refer to language, form and structure.

Model answer

In both poems the past returns without being invited and proves stronger than the present, and in both it is linked to a mother. However, Lawrence experiences its power as painful and humbling, while Bhatt experiences it as joyful and life-giving.

In Piano a woman's singing sweeps the speaker back to childhood. The song has an "insidious mastery" that "Betrays me back", words which suggest a trick or an enemy, and "In spite of myself" shows that he resists. The memories are vivid and sensory: "the boom of the tingling strings" and "the small, poised feet of a mother who smiles as she sings". The present cannot compete; the singer's "clamour" is "vain". In the final lines the past wins completely: "my manhood is cast / Down in the flood of remembrance", and the simile "I weep like a child for the past" shows the grown man reduced to a child. The long lines and rhyming couplets carry the memory forward like the flood he describes.

In Search For My Tongue the past is the speaker's first language, "the mother tongue", which she fears will decay while she lives in a foreign language. The structure makes the past visible: the middle of the poem is written in Gujarati, with its sounds spelt out, so the old language physically interrupts the English. The extended metaphor of a plant growing back while she dreams, as "the bud opens", shows the past returning stronger and forcing the foreign tongue out of the way. Whereas Lawrence's past makes him helpless, Bhatt's gives her strength.

The difference lies in what the past means. For Lawrence it is a lost personal world of childhood that can only be mourned; for Bhatt it is a living cultural identity that can be recovered. Both poems end with the past triumphant, but one speaker weeps and the other blossoms.

Explanation

Strong answers notice the shared idea (the past returning against the speaker's will) and the opposite attitudes (grief in Piano, pride in Search For My Tongue). Analyse the key images of each poem and comment on structure, such as Lawrence's flowing couplets and Bhatt's Gujarati section. Keep the comparison running through the paragraph rather than leaving it to the end.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2 and AO3.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): A cohesive evaluation of how language, form and structure create meanings and effects. Perceptive comparison with a varied range of similarities and/or differences.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Sustained, detailed analysis of language, form and structure and their effects. Effective comparison with a range of similarities and/or differences.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some understanding of the writer's methods, linked to their effects, though partly descriptive. Some comparison, with obvious similarities or differences. NB: the mark cannot go beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Minimal identification of methods; comments are simple or descriptive. Little or no comparison.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid, well-supported points and interpretations). AO2: in Piano the song has an "insidious mastery" that "Betrays me back" to childhood, and "In spite of myself" shows resistance; sensory memories ("the boom of the tingling strings", "the small, poised feet of a mother who smiles as she sings") and the nostalgic "old Sunday evenings at home"; the present singer's "clamour" is "vain"; the metaphor "my manhood is cast / Down in the flood of remembrance" and the simile "I weep like a child for the past" show the past overwhelming the present; three quatrains of long-lined rhyming couplets carry the memory forward like a flood. In Search For My Tongue the past is the speaker's first language, "the mother tongue", which she fears will rot while she lives in a foreign one; the Gujarati section, printed in the middle of the poem with its sounds spelt out, makes the past physically present on the page; the extended metaphor of a plant growing back while she dreams ("the bud opens") shows the past returning stronger and forcing the foreign tongue out of the way; free verse and the direct address to the reader draw us into the problem. AO3: in both poems the past returns involuntarily (through a song; through dreams), and both link it to a mother (a mother at the piano; the mother tongue); Lawrence presents the past's power as painful and unmanning, Bhatt as joyful and empowering; Lawrence's past is a personal memory, Bhatt's a cultural identity; both end with the past triumphing over the present. Weaker responses describe each poem (Level 2); stronger responses compare the attitudes to the past and the methods that create them (Level 3-4).

Question 4

30 marks

Re-read War Photographer and Prayer Before Birth in your anthology.

Compare how the writers present the suffering of innocent people in War Photographer and Prayer Before Birth.

You should make reference to language, form and structure.

Support your answer with examples from the poems.

Model answer

Both Duffy and MacNeice present the suffering that human cruelty inflicts on the innocent, and both criticise a world that allows it. However, Duffy presents suffering that has already happened, seen through the camera of a photographer who must control his feelings, while MacNeice presents suffering that is feared, in the voice of an unborn child who has no control at all.

The two poems give the innocent very different voices. In War Photographer the victims are silent: they exist only as images on film, the "spools of suffering" that the photographer develops in his darkroom. The alliteration of the soft 's' sounds makes the phrase quiet and solemn, while the metaphor turns rolls of film into containers of pain. In Prayer Before Birth the innocent victim speaks for himself. The refrain "I am not yet born" opens stanza after stanza, stressing his helplessness and purity: he has not yet done anything, yet he already fears what the world will do to him. Duffy's victims cannot speak; MacNeice's speaker can do nothing but speak.

Both poets show the causes of suffering. Duffy lists war zones, Belfast, Beirut and Phnom Penh, places of conflict in different parts of the world, so suffering seems universal, and a biblical reference to the shortness of human life adds a sense of tragedy. In the third stanza a stranger's face slowly appears in the developing tray, and the photographer remembers how the dying man's wife cried out. MacNeice instead imagines the horrors in advance: nightmarish creatures, and then human cruelties such as imprisonment, drugs, lies and torture, piled up in long lists with internal rhyme and alliteration that make them sound relentless. Above all, the child fears being made into "a cog in a machine", losing his individuality and becoming a tool of war or of the state. The poem was written in 1944, during the Second World War, when such fears were very real.

The poets also criticise those who allow suffering to continue. Duffy's photographer knows that, of "a hundred agonies" captured on his film, his editor will choose only a few for a Sunday supplement, and that readers will feel a moment of pity before carrying on with their comfortable weekend. The contrast between the war zones and peaceful England exposes their indifference, and in the final lines the photographer looks without expression at a country that does not care. MacNeice's child asks to be forgiven for the sins that others will commit through him, which suggests that innocent people are forced to take part in the world's violence. Both poets therefore blame not only those who cause suffering but also the society that tolerates it.

Religious language appears in both poems. Duffy's photographer works under the red light of his darkroom like a priest preparing to say Mass, so his work becomes a solemn ritual of respect for the dead. MacNeice's whole poem is a prayer, addressed to a higher power with a series of requests to hear, console, protect and forgive. In neither poem, however, does religion bring comfort: the photographer's ritual cannot save the dead, and the child's prayer ends with a stark ultimatum.

The forms reflect the different situations. War Photographer has four six-line stanzas with a regular rhyme scheme, like the neat rows of film in the darkroom, and this control mirrors the professional detachment the photographer needs in order to do his job; the emotion is held in, and it is all the more powerful for that. Prayer Before Birth uses irregular stanzas that mostly grow longer as the fears accumulate, so the shape of the poem swells with panic, until the short final stanza breaks the pattern of the refrain and ends abruptly. Duffy's form contains suffering; MacNeice's overflows with it.

In conclusion, both poems present the suffering of the innocent as the result of human cruelty and indifference. Duffy shows it through silent images and a controlled, regular form that reflects the photographer's restraint, while MacNeice gives the innocent a desperate voice and a form that expands with fear. Together they suggest that the world's suffering demands a response that most people fail to give.

Explanation

This pairing works because the poems look at suffering from opposite positions: a witness to suffering that has happened, and an innocent who fears suffering to come. Strong answers compare the voices (silent victims against a pleading child), the criticism of indifferent people and the forms (controlled stanzas against expanding ones). Because both poems are in copyright, refer to stanzas and describe images precisely rather than relying on long quotations.

Mark scheme
  1. 30 marks

    Levels of response (30 marks). AO2 (15 marks) and AO3 (15 marks).
    Level 5 (25-30 marks): The response is a cohesive evaluation of the interrelationship of the language, form and structure used by the writer and their effect on the reader. The response compares and contrasts the poems perceptively with a varied and comprehensive range of similarities and/or differences between the poems. Discriminating use of relevant examples to support the response.
    Level 4 (19-24 marks): The response is focused and detailed, and the analysis of the language, form and structure used by the writer and their effect on the reader is sustained. The response compares and contrasts the poems effectively, considering a wide range of similarities and/or differences between the poems. Use of fully relevant examples to support the response.
    Level 3 (13-18 marks): The response shows an understanding of the range of language, form and structure used by the writer and links these to their effect on the reader. The response compares and contrasts a range of points and considers some similarities and/or differences between the poems. Use of clearly relevant examples to support the response.
    Level 2 (7-12 marks): The response may be largely descriptive, with some comment on the language, form and structure used by the writer. There are some underdeveloped comparisons and contrasts presented, with obvious similarities and/or differences between the poems. Some use of relevant examples to support the response. NB: the mark cannot go beyond the top of Level 2 if only ONE poem has been considered.
    Level 1 (1-6 marks): The response is simple and the identification of language, form and structure used by the writer is minimal. There is little or no comparison of the two poems. Limited use of relevant examples to support the response.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid, well-supported points and interpretations). AO2 War Photographer: a photographer develops his pictures of war in his darkroom in England; the alliterative metaphor "spools of suffering" turns rolls of film into containers of pain; the red light of the darkroom and the comparison of the photographer to a priest preparing to say Mass give his work a solemn, sacred quality; the list of war zones (Belfast, Beirut, Phnom Penh) shows that suffering is universal; a biblical echo about the shortness of human life stresses mortality; a stranger's face slowly appears in the developing tray, and the photographer remembers the dying man's wife crying out; the editor will choose only a few of "a hundred agonies" for a Sunday supplement, and readers will be moved only briefly; the contrast between the war zones and comfortable rural England exposes indifference; the photographer finally looks without expression at a country that does not care; four six-line stanzas with a regular rhyme scheme reflect the order and control he needs to do his job. AO2 Prayer Before Birth: written in 1944, during the Second World War; an unborn child's prayer to a higher power; the refrain "I am not yet born" stresses innocence and helplessness; lists of threats, from nightmare creatures to human cruelties such as imprisonment, drugs, lies and torture, use internal rhyme and alliteration; the child asks for the comfort of nature and asks to be forgiven for the sins that others will commit through him; the fear of becoming "a cog in a machine", losing individuality to war or the state; the eight stanzas generally grow longer as the fears accumulate (the seventh is the longest), and the short final stanza abandons the refrain and ends with a stark ultimatum. AO3: both present innocent people suffering from human cruelty and indifference; Duffy shows suffering that has already happened, MacNeice suffering that is feared; Duffy's victims are silent images, while MacNeice's speaker voices his own fear; Duffy's controlled, regular form contains emotion, MacNeice's expanding stanzas let fear overflow; both criticise people who allow suffering (the indifferent readers; those who would corrupt the child); both use religious language (the Mass; the prayer), but in neither does it bring comfort. Weaker responses describe the situations (Level 2); stronger responses compare the voices, imagery and forms (Level 4-5).

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.