Re-read Piano and La Belle Dame sans Merci in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present enchantment in Piano and La Belle Dame sans Merci.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Both Piano and La Belle Dame sans Merci show a man held under a spell that begins with a woman's song and leaves him diminished and alone. Keats's knight is enchanted by a mysterious, supernatural lady; Lawrence's speaker is enchanted by memory itself, set off by a singer in the present. In both poems the enchantment brings intense pleasure, but it ends in loss.
Song is the source of the spell in each poem. Lawrence's opening is quiet and hypnotic: "Softly, in the dusk, a woman is singing to me". The sibilance and the gentle adverb lull the reader, and "dusk", a time between light and dark, is the kind of threshold where enchantments happen. Keats's lady also enchants through song: "sidelong would she bend, and sing / A faery's song". The word "faery" makes her power supernatural, and the knight's attention is completely captured: he "nothing else saw all day long". Both men are transfixed, but the knight is seduced by a stranger, whereas Lawrence's singer matters only because her song opens a door into his own past.
Both poets present the spell as something that overpowers the man's will. Lawrence's speaker fights it: "In spite of myself, the insidious mastery of song / Betrays me back". "insidious" suggests something sly and creeping, "mastery" suggests domination, and "Betrays" suggests that he has been tricked. Keats's knight does not resist at all; he gives himself up. He makes "a garland for her head", sets her on his "pacing steed", and believes her when, "in language strange", she says "I love thee true". Because her language is strange, he cannot really understand her, so his trust is part of the enchantment. Finally the ghosts warn him: "La Belle Dame sans Merci / Thee hath in thrall!" To be in thrall is to be enslaved, which matches Lawrence's "mastery": both men have lost their freedom.
The spell is also sweet and alluring. Lawrence's enchantment is the warmth of childhood: the child "pressing the small, poised feet of a mother who smiles as she sings", and the "hymns in the cosy parlour" while there is "winter outside". In the third stanza he names it directly: "The glamour / Of childish days is upon me". 'Glamour' once meant a magic spell, and "upon me" makes it feel like something cast over him. Keats's enchantment is sensual and exotic: the lady finds him "roots of relish sweet, / And honey wild, and manna-dew", food that seems to come from another world, and takes him to "her elfin grot". Lawrence's spell is domestic and innocent, Keats's dangerous and erotic, but both offer the man a lost paradise.
In both poems the enchantment ends in desolation. The knight wakes from his dream "On the cold hill's side", in a landscape where "The sedge has withered from the lake, / And no birds sing." The absence of birdsong is striking after the lady's song: the music has gone and left silence. Lawrence's speaker ends in tears: "my manhood is cast / Down in the flood of remembrance, I weep like a child for the past". Both men are diminished - the knight "palely loitering", the man reduced to a child. Yet Keats's knight has lost something that may never have been real, whereas Lawrence's speaker grieves for a real past that cannot return.
Form and structure intensify these effects. Keats uses a ballad with a frame: a questioner asks "O what can ail thee, knight-at-arms" before the knight tells his story. The short final line of each quatrain, such as "And no birds sing", cuts the stanza off abruptly, and the last stanza echoes the first, so the knight is trapped in a circle - the spell never lets him go. Lawrence uses three quatrains of rhyming couplets, a song-like pattern that suits a poem about music, but his long lines seem to strain against the form as the emotion builds. His structure moves from the present into the past and back to a present overwhelmed by the past, ending on the word "past". Both forms are musical, as if the poems themselves cast a spell.
In conclusion, both poets present enchantment as a beautiful but destructive power that takes a man out of his ordinary world and leaves him unable to return to it. Keats's knight is the victim of a mysterious woman, while Lawrence's speaker is the victim of his own longing for home, childhood and his mother; for both, the sweetness of the spell makes the loss more painful.