Re-read Half-caste and Do not go gentle into that good night in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present strong feelings in Half-caste and Do not go gentle into that good night.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Both Half-caste and Do not go gentle into that good night are poems of intense feeling addressed directly to another person. Agard's speaker confronts a listener who has used a racist label; Thomas's speaker pleads with his dying father. Both express anger through insistent commands and refrains, but Agard's anger is mixed with humour and pride, while Thomas's is mixed with love and grief.
Both poems are built on imperatives. Thomas's title is itself a command, and his speaker repeatedly urges the dying to rage against "the dying of the light". The metaphor of light for life and night for death makes the struggle elemental, and the doubled command to rage gives the line a furious, pounding rhythm. Agard's central command is "Explain yuself", repeated at the start of section after section and followed each time by a question asking what the listener means. Thomas commands his father to fight; Agard commands his listener to justify himself. In both poems the repeated imperative carries the speaker's strength of feeling.
Refrains intensify these feelings in different ways. Thomas writes a villanelle: nineteen lines with only two rhyme sounds, in which two refrains return again and again. The strict form makes the plea obsessive, as though the speaker cannot stop repeating himself in the face of death. Agard's refrain works within free verse; it returns at irregular intervals, introducing each new example, so his frustration builds with every repetition. Thomas's feeling is held tightly within an inherited form, while Agard's breaks free of formal rules altogether, just as his speaker refuses the rules others impose on him.
Both poets build their case through examples. Thomas lists four kinds of men - the wise, the good, the wild and the "Grave men" - who all, in different ways, refuse to accept death quietly; the pun on grave, meaning both serious and the place of burial, adds a dark irony. Agard also presents a series of examples: Picasso's "half-caste canvas", the English sky where "light an shadow" mix, and Tchaikovsky's "half-caste symphony". Thomas's examples are meant to inspire his father to fight; Agard's are meant to make the listener's term collapse under its own absurdity.
The feelings in both poems are mixed. Agard's anger is sharpened by wit: the pun "till dem overcast" and the self-mocking image of being able only to "cast half-a-shadow" turn fury into ridicule. Yet anger breaks through openly in the expletive "ah rass". Thomas's anger is inseparable from love and grief: he asks his father to curse and bless him with "fierce tears", an oxymoron that captures the son's longing for any sign of his father's strength. Agard's mixed feelings are directed outwards, at prejudice; Thomas's are directed at someone he loves.
Light and dark imagery appears in both poems. For Thomas, light is life, and its dying is death, so the light of the world itself becomes a matter of life and death. Agard's light and dark are images of mixture: light and shadow mixing in the sky, black and white keys sounding together in a symphony. Thomas wants the light to be fought for; Agard wants light and dark to be recognised as belonging together.
The endings show where the feelings lead. Thomas's final stanza turns directly to his father, on the edge of death, and the two refrains come together for the last time, so the general argument becomes a private, desperate plea. Agard's ending turns from attack to invitation: the listener must come back with the "whole of yu mind", and the speaker will tell "de other half" of his story. Thomas's poem ends in grief that cannot change the outcome, whereas Agard's ends in hope that the listener can still change.
In conclusion, both poets present strong feelings through direct address, repetition and examples. Thomas channels love, anger and grief through a rigid form that mirrors the inevitability of death, while Agard expresses anger, pride and humour in a free, rule-breaking voice that insists on being heard.
Explanation
'Strong feelings' covers anger, frustration, pride, love and grief, so compare which feelings each speaker shows and how they are mixed. The best links are the insistent imperatives, the refrains (free and irregular against a strict villanelle), the use of examples and the endings. Analyse methods in both poems in each paragraph, and comment on how each form shapes the feeling.