Re-read Do not go gentle into that good night and Prayer Before Birth in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present the value of human life in Do not go gentle into that good night and Prayer Before Birth.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Do not go gentle into that good night and Prayer Before Birth stand at opposite ends of a human life: Thomas's speaker addresses a father who is dying, while MacNeice's speaker is a child who has not yet been born. Yet both poems are urgent prayers that reveal what makes a life valuable. For Thomas, life is precious enough to be fought for to the very last moment; for MacNeice's unborn child, life is valuable only if it can be lived as a full human being.
Both poems are pleas to a powerful listener. Every stanza of MacNeice's poem except the last begins "I am not yet born", followed by a request such as "O hear me". The repeated opening is like a response in a church service, and the imperatives - asking to be heard, consoled, provided for, forgiven - show the speaker's complete vulnerability. Thomas's poem is also built on repeated commands. The title warns against going gently, the second refrain urges "Rage, rage", and in the final stanza the son admits that he is praying: "I pray". Both speakers beg someone more powerful: MacNeice's child appeals to God, Thomas's son to his father.
The poets locate the value of life in different things. MacNeice's child longs for the natural world - water, grass, trees, sky and birds - and for an inner light to show him the way, so a valuable life is one in harmony with nature and conscience. Thomas presents value through achievement and intensity. His four kinds of men all regret how they lived: the wise men's words "forked no lightning"; the good men lament, as "the last wave by" passes, that their deeds were too fragile to shine; the wild men learn "too late" what they were losing. A life matters, Thomas suggests, if it burns brightly, and his men fight death because they have not yet lived fully enough.
Both poets fear a life emptied of humanity. MacNeice's child dreads being turned into "a lethal automaton" or "a cog in a machine": the metaphors describe a person reduced to a mechanical part, used by others, perhaps for war. The long, breathless lists of the seventh stanza pile up these threats until the lines themselves seem to overwhelm him. Thomas's fear is of a passive death, of going quietly into darkness. His grave men, near the end, see with "blinding sight" how much brighter their lives could have been. For MacNeice the danger is a dehumanised life; for Thomas it is a death accepted too easily.
Strikingly, both poems include cursing. MacNeice's child asks to be prepared, like an actor rehearsing a part, for a life in which, among other trials, "my children curse me": a life can be damaged by forces beyond one's control. Thomas's son begs his father to "Curse, bless" him, a paradox that values any strong feeling over silence. For MacNeice a curse is a sign of a life gone wrong; for Thomas even a curse would be welcome, because it would prove that his father is still fighting.
The endings show how highly each speaker values life. MacNeice's final stanza is only two lines long, and its last words, "Otherwise kill me", are shocking: if he cannot be fully human, the child would rather not live at all. Life is valuable only on certain terms. Thomas ends with both refrains together, a final command to fight against "the dying of the light". His speaker will accept no terms from death; his father's life is worth defending whatever its condition.
Form and structure express these attitudes. MacNeice's free verse has stanzas of changing length: each begins with the same plea and then swells into lists, and the poem ends in a stark, short stanza, so the shape mirrors growing fear followed by a final, blunt demand. Thomas's villanelle is rigidly controlled, with only two rhyme sounds and two refrains returning again and again; the strict pattern suits a son who refuses to let go. Both poets use repetition like prayer, but MacNeice's prayer grows more desperate and fragmented, while Thomas's tightens into a closing couplet of commands.
In conclusion, both poems present life as precious and fragile, and both take the form of an urgent prayer. MacNeice's child values a life of freedom, nature and humanity so highly that he would refuse any lesser life, while Thomas's son values his father's life so highly that he demands that he fight death to the end.