Re-read Remember and Prayer Before Birth in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present a speaker who pleads with another in Remember and Prayer Before Birth.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Remember and Prayer Before Birth are both spoken as pleas to someone who has power over the speaker's fate, and both stand at the border of life: Rossetti's speaker anticipates her death, while MacNeice's speaker has not yet been born. Both use repeated requests to express vulnerability, but Rossetti's pleas grow gentler and more selfless, while MacNeice's grow more desperate until they end in a shocking demand.
Both poems are built on repeated imperatives. Rossetti begins with "Remember me", repeats it at the start of the fifth line, and narrows it to "Only remember me". The repetition is insistent but quiet; the speaker asks for nothing more than memory. MacNeice's speaker opens almost every stanza with "I am not yet born" and then a request - "O hear me", "console me", "forgive me" - so the poem sounds like a litany, a sequence of prayers in a church service. Rossetti's requests are personal and intimate, made to a lover; MacNeice's are made to God, with a rising sense of dread.
The listeners differ, and so does the speaker's position. Rossetti addresses someone she loves and who loves her: he holds her hand and tells her "of our future that you planned". Her pleas are about how he should behave after she has gone. MacNeice's child addresses a higher power because he fears the human world itself, and his pleas are for protection. Rossetti is concerned for the person she speaks to; MacNeice's child is afraid for himself, and for what the world will make of him.
Both speakers consider what might be lost. Rossetti thinks of the gentle routines of love that death will end: "When you can no more hold me by the hand, / Nor I half turn to go yet turning stay." The repetition of "no more" and the hesitating rhythm of the half-turn make the loss tender. MacNeice's child fears losing his humanity before he has even lived: he dreads being made into "a cog in a machine", a mechanical part with no identity of its own. Rossetti fears losing a relationship; MacNeice's child fears losing a self.
The most striking difference is how the pleas develop. Rossetti's sonnet turns at "Yet", and her requests become generous: "Yet if you should forget me for a while / And afterwards remember, do not grieve". The imperative "do not grieve" is now for his sake, not hers, and the final lines put his happiness above her memory: "Better by far you should forget and smile / Than that you should remember and be sad." MacNeice's pleas move the other way. They become longer and more breathless, piling up threats in lists, until the last stanza shrinks to two lines and the final words, "Otherwise kill me", reject a life without humanity. Rossetti lets go of her demand; MacNeice's child hardens his into an ultimatum.
Both poems also touch on prayer and faith. Rossetti, a devout Christian, notes that after her death it will be "late to counsel then or pray", and she imagines "the darkness and corruption" of the grave, a reminder that the body decays. MacNeice's whole poem is a prayer, as its title says, and the child's repeated plea "O hear me" is addressed to God. In Rossetti, prayer becomes useless after death; in MacNeice, prayer is the only defence before birth.
Form and structure reflect the development of the pleas. Rossetti's Petrarchan sonnet is compact and ordered: its octave, rhyming ABBAABBA, contains the request to be remembered, and its sestet, after the volta, releases the lover. The calm iambic pentameter suits a speaker who is resigned and composed. MacNeice writes in free verse, with stanzas of changing length; each begins with the same words and then swells with lists and internal rhymes, so the shape of the poem expresses fear growing out of control, before the curt final stanza. Rossetti's structure moves towards peace; MacNeice's moves towards crisis.
In conclusion, both poems present pleas made at the edges of life, and both reveal vulnerability through repeated requests. Rossetti's speaker moves from asking to be remembered to asking only that her lover be happy, an act of selfless love, while MacNeice's unborn child moves from asking for protection to demanding death rather than a dehumanised life, a cry of protest against the world he must enter.
Explanation
Both speakers plead, but with different listeners, needs and outcomes. Compare the repeated imperatives, who is addressed, what each fears losing, how the pleas develop (gentler in Rossetti, more desperate in MacNeice), the role of prayer and the forms. Prayer Before Birth is in copyright, so quote short phrases and describe its lists and stanza shapes in your own words.