Re-read Prayer Before Birth and Blessing in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present vulnerability in Prayer Before Birth and Blessing.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Prayer Before Birth and Blessing both present people who are vulnerable because they depend on forces they cannot control. MacNeice gives a voice to an unborn child who fears the cruelty of the world it is about to enter; Dharker describes a poor community in a drought, waiting for water that comes only by chance. Both poets use prayer, water and the bodies of children to show vulnerability, but MacNeice's child speaks its own terror, while Dharker watches a community whose moment of joy cannot hide how fragile it is.
The poets present vulnerability from different positions. MacNeice writes in the first person, and the refrain "I am not yet born", which opens every stanza but the last, reminds us that the speaker has no body in the world, no power and no voice except its prayer. Each refrain is followed by an imperative plea - to be heard, consoled, forgiven or filled with strength - so the whole poem depends on a listener who never replies. Dharker, by contrast, observes from outside. Her opening simile, in which the skin "cracks like a pod", makes the drought physical, and the flat statement that follows tells us that water is always short. The people never speak; their vulnerability is shown through their bodies and their actions.
Both poets show vulnerable people depending on a power above them. MacNeice's poem is a prayer to God, or to whoever will listen, and the child begs that "the man who is beast" should not come near it. Dharker's community depends on two powers: the city, whose "municipal" pipe brings water only when it bursts, and a divine power, since even an imagined drip sounds like the voice of "a kindly god". The burst pipe is a stroke of "fortune", so the people's survival depends on luck and on the authorities' failure. In both poems the vulnerable cannot help themselves; they can only hope that someone, or something, will answer.
The threats are different in kind. MacNeice's child fears what human beings will do to it. In the second stanza the human race may imprison it - "tall walls wall me" - and drug, deceive and torture it; the internal rhyme and the noun turned into a verb make each threat close in, and each phrase ends with "me", the child as the object of someone else's action. Dharker's threat is poverty and neglect rather than cruelty. The community lives in huts, and when the water comes the people rush out with metal pots, plastic buckets and finally their own hands, a list that shows how little they have. MacNeice's child is vulnerable to deliberate harm; Dharker's people are vulnerable because they have been left without what they need.
Water connects the two poems. In MacNeice's third stanza the child asks for "water to dandle me", along with grass, trees and sky: nature imagined as a parent rocking a baby. Later, water becomes an image of fragility, as the child fears being spilled "like water held" in the hands, its whole self lost. For Dharker, water is the gift that relieves vulnerability: the burst pipe fills the dry streets with noise and light, and the people gather as "a congregation", as if the water were holy. In both poems water is precious, but MacNeice's child fears that its own self could drain away like water, while Dharker's people are briefly saved by it.
Children are the most vulnerable figures in both poems. MacNeice's speaker prays for "a white light" to guide it and fears being made "a cog in a machine", one replaceable part of a system that does not care. Dharker ends her poem with naked children screaming with joy in "the liquid sun", their wet skin shining as if polished. Yet her final image is of the blessing singing over their "small bones": the phrase reminds us that these children are thin and fragile, and that the joy will pass when the water stops. Both poets use the bodies of children to make the reader feel protective.
Form and structure reinforce the vulnerability. Both poets write in free verse whose stanzas swell before a shorter ending. MacNeice's stanzas lengthen as the threats multiply, reaching ten lines in the seventh stanza, and then the poem collapses into a two-line final stanza that drops the refrain and ends with the stark demand "kill me": the child would rather die than lose its humanity. Dharker's stanzas grow from two lines to eleven as the water rushes in, and her long sentence spills across the stanza break before the shorter final stanza narrows to the children. MacNeice's shape enacts mounting panic; Dharker's enacts a flood that rises and then subsides.
In conclusion, both poets present vulnerability as dependence: on a listener who may not answer, on a pipe that may not burst, on a world that may not be kind. MacNeice's child speaks with growing desperation because it knows what the world can do; Dharker's community celebrates a moment of relief, but the final "small bones" leaves the reader aware that its vulnerability remains.