Re-read If- in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present ideas about how to live a good life in If- and one other poem from the anthology.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
If- and Poem at Thirty-Nine both present the values a parent passes to a child, and both place honesty, self-reliance and hard work at the centre of a good life. But Kipling's poem is an idealised code addressed forward to a son who has not yet proved himself, whereas Walker's looks back at a dead father whose lessons she has absorbed and adapted in her own life as a woman.
The voices are reversed. In If- the parent speaks and the child is silent: the conditionals tell the son what he must become, and only the last words, "my son", identify him. Walker writes as the grown child, and her poem is driven by memory and longing; the exclamation "How I miss my father!" is a direct cry of grief that Kipling's restrained voice would never allow itself. Kipling's poem looks to the future; Walker's measures the present against the past.
Both poets value honesty, but Walker shows its cost. Kipling's ideal man, when "lied about", must not "deal in lies"; honesty is a principle stated in the abstract. Walker remembers that her father taught her the importance of "telling the truth", but also that telling the truth sometimes brought punishment - a hint that he could not always bear the truths he had taught her to tell. Her picture of the lesson is complicated and human: the teacher of honesty was not perfect. Kipling's code has no such contradictions; its ideal man is consistent in every situation.
Money offers another link. In If- the ideal man can risk "one heap of all your winnings" on "one turn of pitch-and-toss" and lose without complaint; wealth matters less than composure, and the final reward places being "a Man" above "the Earth and everything that's in it". Walker's father taught her careful, practical skills with money, which she came to see as a way out of the hard life he had known. Where Kipling presents money as something a strong man can gamble and lose, Walker presents it as security and escape, shaped by the poverty in her family's past.
The poets also differ in how the lessons are learned. Kipling's are instructions; Walker's are learned by example. She remembers her father's pleasure in cooking and in sharing food, and now she cooks like him, but her metaphor of "seasoning none of my life" in any fixed or repeated way shows variety. The cooking metaphor suggests that she has inherited his values but made them her own, adding variety and freedom. Kipling's son, by contrast, must match a single fixed pattern, set out line by line.
Gender shapes both poems. Kipling's ideal is explicitly male: the reward is to "be a Man", and modern readers may notice that the advice is addressed only to a son. Walker ends with a daughter who has inherited her father's qualities and believes he would have admired "the woman I've become", a woman whose practical and creative skills cross traditional gender roles. Walker shows that the lessons of a good life are not reserved for sons.
Form reinforces these differences. Kipling's regular octaves of iambic pentameter, alternate rhyme and single conditional sentence give his advice the authority of a creed, and the anaphora of "If" makes it sound like a series of tests. Walker uses free verse with very short lines, often of only two or three words, which slows the reader and makes each memory feel separate and precious. Her poem moves from past to present and ends with a quiet, reflective image of the poet gazing into a fire, in contrast to Kipling's triumphant exclamation.
In conclusion, both poems present a good life as one of honesty, effort and independence. Kipling sets out a heroic, almost impossible ideal from the outside; Walker shows how real lessons are learned imperfectly, through love and example, and reshaped by the next generation.
Explanation
With 'one other poem' questions, choose a partner that really engages with the focus; Poem at Thirty-Nine works well because it is also about a parent's lessons, seen from the child's side. Compare who teaches whom, which values matter, how they are learned, and how form presents them, analysing both poems in each paragraph. Avoid simply listing the values in each poem.