Re-read Hide and Seek and If- in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present growing up in Hide and Seek and If-.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Hide and Seek and If- both address a young person as 'you' and are full of instructions, and both can be read as poems about growing up. Kipling's father figure sets out the qualities a boy needs to become a man, presenting growing up as a moral achievement; Scannell's speaker guides a child through a game that ends in the discovery of loneliness, presenting growing up as a painful loss of innocence.
The clearest link is the direct address and the instructing voice. If- is one long conditional sentence built on the repeated "If you can", which piles up challenges for the son: to "keep your head when all about you / Are losing theirs", to "trust yourself when all men doubt you", to "meet with Triumph and Disaster / And treat those two impostors just the same". Scannell's speaker also gives commands - from the opening call of "Come and find me" to the urgent line ending "Hide in your blindness" - but these are tactics for a game, not rules for life. Kipling's 'you' is an imagined future man; Scannell's is a child in one particular moment, and the present tense makes us share it.
Both poems value self-control. Kipling's son must "wait and not be tired by waiting" and "hold on when there is nothing in you". Scannell's child shows exactly this endurance: keeping still and silent as the seekers come close, and staying hidden long after they have gone, even when "It seems a long time" and the cold becomes painful. Ironically, the child's perfect discipline is what leads to abandonment. Kipling promises that self-control will be rewarded - "Yours is the Earth and everything that's in it" - whereas Scannell shows a child who follows the rules perfectly and is left with nothing.
The poets treat winning and losing differently. Kipling calls Triumph and Disaster "impostors" and urges the son to "lose, and start again at your beginnings / And never breathe a word about your loss". Scannell's child bursts out with "I've won", only to find the victory meaningless because no one is there to see it. Triumph turns to disaster in a moment, which shows how deceptive both can be, just as Kipling warns - but the child, unlike Kipling's ideal man, has had no chance to learn how to meet such a disaster calmly.
Relationships with others differ too. Kipling's ideal man stands apart from the crowd, letting "all men count with you, but none too much", so independence is presented as strength. Scannell's child depends entirely on the seekers, and their unexplained departure, heard only as a "laughter scuffle", leaves the child exposed. The final question, "where are they who sought you", shows that the child must now face the world alone - perhaps the first step towards an adult understanding that others can let you down.
Form and structure reflect these attitudes. If- is tightly controlled: four eight-line stanzas with regular alternating rhyme and a steady iambic rhythm, building through a long chain of conditions to the triumphant final line, "you'll be a Man, my son!" The structure delays the reward, as if growing up is a long test. Scannell's single unbroken block, with only scattered rhymes and a looser rhythm, moves from excitement to isolation and ends not with an exclamation but with a question. Kipling's ending confirms the boy's arrival in manhood; Scannell's leaves the child stranded in the "darkening garden".
The voices also differ in confidence. Kipling's speaker is certain and authoritative, speaking from experience. Scannell's speaker is confident at first, predicting where the seekers will search, but by the end even this guiding voice has no answer to give.
In conclusion, both poems present growing up as a test of character addressed to 'you'. Kipling offers a confident, idealised map of how to become a man, while Scannell shows the moment a child's trust in the game is broken, suggesting that growing up involves not only self-discipline but the painful discovery that others may not play by the same rules.