Re-read The Tyger and La Belle Dame sans Merci in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present beauty in The Tyger and La Belle Dame sans Merci.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
The Tyger and La Belle Dame sans Merci both present a beauty that is also dangerous. Blake marvels at a creature whose beauty is inseparable from its terror; Keats tells of a lady whose beauty enchants a knight and then destroys him. Both poets suggest that the most powerful beauty is otherworldly, and both leave its mystery unexplained.
In both poems beauty and danger are fused. Blake's tiger is "burning bright": the metaphor captures its glowing coat, but fire also destroys. The oxymoron "fearful symmetry" sums up the paradox - a perfectly balanced, beautiful design that inspires fear. Keats's lady is "Full beautiful - a faery's child", and the dash turns admiration into a hint that she is not human. His triplet "Her hair was long, her foot was light, / And her eyes were wild" lists conventional signs of beauty and grace, but ends, on the stressed final word of the short fourth line, with wildness. In both poems, the closer we look at beauty, the more dangerous it becomes.
Both poets focus on the eyes. Blake asks in what "distant deeps or skies" there "Burnt the fire of thine eyes", so the tiger's gaze blazes with the same fire as its body. The knight is fascinated by the lady's eyes: they are "wild" when he first sees her, and later he shuts "her wild wild eyes / With kisses four". The repetition suggests that he cannot escape their untamed power. Fire in the tiger's eyes and wildness in the lady's both signal something that cannot be controlled.
The beauty in each poem has an otherworldly source. Blake imagines an "immortal hand or eye" framing the tiger, and the blacksmith imagery shows that such beauty has to be forged with "dread grasp". Keats's lady comes from fairyland: she sings "A faery's song" and leads the knight to "her elfin grot". Both settings are dark or half-lit: the tiger burns in "the forests of the night", and the knight's dream of the lady's victims takes place "in the gloam". Beauty shines out of darkness in both, and darkness surrounds it.
The effects of beauty differ. The tiger's beauty provokes questions about God: "Did he who made the Lamb make thee?" The speaker is awed, but he is not harmed; he remains an observer. The lady's beauty destroys the knight. The pale kings and warriors cry, "La Belle Dame sans Merci / Thee hath in thrall!", and when he wakes, his own beauty has faded: the questioner sees a "fading rose" on his cheeks that "Fast withereth too". In Blake, beauty leads to philosophical wonder; in Keats, it leads to ruin.
Form and structure are strikingly similar. Both poets use short, song-like quatrains: Blake's rhyming couplets with a hammering trochaic beat, Keats's ballad stanzas with a short, fading fourth line. Both poems are circular. Blake's last stanza repeats the first, but "Could" becomes "Dare", so the speaker's awe has deepened. Keats's last stanza repeats the first, so the knight is still "Alone and palely loitering" where the questioner found him. In both, the return to the beginning shows that beauty's mystery cannot be solved: the speaker cannot answer his question, and the knight cannot escape.
The voices differ, however. Blake's speaker addresses the tiger directly in a series of questions, never answered. Keats uses two voices, a questioner and the knight, so beauty is seen first through its effects on the knight's body and then through his memory.
In conclusion, both Romantic-period poems present beauty as dangerous, otherworldly and beyond understanding. Blake's tiger shows that beauty and terror may be part of God's design; Keats's lady shows that beauty can enslave and destroy. Both leave the reader, like the speaker and the knight, spellbound and unsettled.