Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/26

Klara and the Sun (Kazuo Ishiguro)

Practise 28 exam-style questions on Klara and the Sun (Kazuo Ishiguro) for Edexcel International GCSE English Literature (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 28 questions
  • 1–40 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

What has happened to Josie's older sister, Sal, before the novel begins?

Choose your answer.

  • She has died
  • She has left for college
  • She was never lifted
  • She lives with the Father

Model answer

She has died.

Explanation

Sal's death explains the Mother's terror of losing Josie and her plan for the 'portrait'. Miss Helen's story of once seeing the Mother walking with a figure who looked like Sal, after Sal's death, is an early, unsettling clue. Keep the facts precise: Sal is the older sister, and she was lifted.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    She has died

    If more than one option is given, 0 marks. Sal died of an illness when Josie was younger; the novel strongly implies that her death was linked to the risks of being 'lifted', since the Father had warned against lifting Josie after what happened to Sal. Josie, not Sal, goes to college at the end of the novel. Rick, not Sal, is the child who was never lifted. The Father lives apart from the family, in a community of former professionals.

Question 2

3 marks

In Part Four, Miss Helen and Rick meet Vance in the city.

Explain why the meeting matters to them and why it goes badly.

Model answer

Vance has influence at Atlas Brookings, one of the few colleges that takes unlifted students, so he could give Rick the future that lifting would otherwise have guaranteed, and Miss Helen hopes their past acquaintance will persuade him. The meeting goes badly because Vance dislikes being asked openly for a favour, and he resents the way Miss Helen treated him in the past.

Explanation

This scene shows how unfair the world of the novel is for unlifted children: Rick's talent is not enough, so his mother must beg a favour. Note that the outcome is left uncertain - Klara thinks Vance may still help - and in Part Six Rick does not go to college at all.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Vance has influence at Atlas Brookings (he chairs its Founders' Committee), a college that accepts a small number of unlifted students

    One mark per separate point, max 3.

  2. 1 mark

    Rick, who is unlifted, needs a place there to have a good future // Miss Helen hopes Vance will help because of their past acquaintance

  3. 1 mark

    Vance is annoyed that they openly ask for a favour (he says favours work best unspoken) // he resents the way Miss Helen ignored / treated him in the past

  4. 1 mark

    It shows that an unlifted child's chances depend on connections and favours, not just ability (Rick's talent with drones is not enough)

    Do not accept 'Vance refuses because Rick is not clever enough': he is impressed by Rick's drawings.

Question 3

12 marks

Explore how Ishiguro presents Klara's first visit to Mr McBain's barn in Part Three.

Write a focused answer of two or three paragraphs.

Model answer

Ishiguro presents Klara's first visit to the barn as a kind of pilgrimage, and it is one of the most moving passages in the novel. Her reasoning is careful: the Sun once saved Beggar Man, but he is busy, so his attention must be drawn to Josie. Like a believer approaching a shrine, she sets out at sunset, alone and frightened. The fields are harder than she expected, and only Rick's help - he carries her part of the way - gets her there, a quiet sign of his loyalty to Josie and his growing trust in Klara.

The barn itself tests her faith. It is half-built and open to the wind, and she can see that the Sun goes down beyond it, not inside. Yet she decides that it is still his last stop each evening, a small act of interpretation that keeps her belief alive. Inside, she pleads with him to "make Josie better" as he did Beggar Man. The scene follows the shape of a prayer: a request, then doubt, then humility. She begins to feel foolish, sensing that the Sun may not see Josie as separate from all the other humans, and she realises she has been presumptuous. So she apologises and offers something in return - to destroy the Cootings Machine and its Pollution. The bargain looks forward to her sacrifice of P-E-G Nine solution in Part Four.

The reader's response is double. Klara's logic is touchingly naive - she treats the Sun as a person who can be persuaded - yet her humility and selflessness are entirely admirable. Ishiguro neither confirms nor mocks her faith, leaving us to wonder, as we will at the end, whether love and hope can work a kind of miracle.

Explanation

Focus on how Ishiguro presents the visit: the pilgrimage structure, the shape of a prayer (plea, doubt, apology, offer), the half-built barn and the reader's double view of Klara's faith. Use Rick's role and the link forward to the Cootings Machine. Avoid simply retelling the walk.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO1.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Assured knowledge of the text, a perceptive critical style and discriminating use of examples.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Thorough knowledge of the text, a sustained critical style and fully relevant examples.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Sound knowledge of the text with clearly relevant examples; may be partly narrative.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited knowledge; simple, largely narrative, with few relevant examples.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid, well-supported points and interpretations). AO1: as Josie grows weaker, Klara reasons that the Sun is busy and must have his attention drawn to Josie, remembering how he revived Beggar Man. She asks Rick about the path to the barn and sets out just before sunset; the fields are harder to cross than she expected, but Rick, watching from his house, comes after her and carries her part of the way. The barn is half-built and open to the wind, and she sees that the Sun sets beyond it, yet she decides it is still the last place he visits. Inside, the furniture reminds her of the store. She concentrates and pleads with the Sun to "make Josie better" as he did Beggar Man; then doubt comes - she feels foolish, sensing that the Sun may not see Josie as separate from other humans - so she apologises for her presumption and proposes to please him by destroying the Cootings Machine and its Pollution. Rick waits for her in the dark, and she urges him to try for Atlas Brookings. Presentation: religious parallels - a pilgrimage, a prayer, a bargain, a promised sacrifice; the barn as a kind of shrine; Klara's careful logic and humility; the reader's double view - touching and naive at once; Rick's kindness and loyalty; foreshadowing of the P-E-G Nine sacrifice. Answers that retell the journey stay in Level 2; stronger answers analyse the religious language and Klara's mixture of reason and faith.

Question 4

40 marks

Examine the importance of Mr Capaldi and his 'portrait' of Josie in the novel.

You must consider the context of the novel in your answer.

Model answer

Mr Capaldi appears in only a few scenes, but his 'portrait' of Josie is the hidden engine of the novel. It creates suspense, reveals the true purpose of Klara's purchase, sets out the novel's central philosophical question and prepares for Klara's final answer to it. Without the portrait, Klara and the Sun would be a gentle story about a sick child; with it, it becomes a novel about what makes a person who they are.

Ishiguro builds the portrait slowly. Josie sits for it in the city, Rick finds it strange that she has never been shown it, and Melania Housekeeper privately warns Klara that the man is creepy. Klara reports all this without understanding it, and the reader's unease grows. Earlier hints - the Mother making Klara copy Josie's walk in the store, and asking her to be Josie at Morgan's Falls - suddenly connect. This is Ishiguro's typical method: a narrator who sees everything but understands little, so that the reader assembles the truth before she does.

The revelation in Part Four is one of the novel's most unsettling scenes. Klara is asked to fill in a questionnaire about Josie, then slips through the Purple Door and finds an artificial Josie suspended in the air, almost perfect but wearing an expression Josie never wears. The plan is then explained: if Josie dies, Klara will inhabit this body and 'continue' her. Mr Capaldi defends it with calm conviction. He tells the Mother that their generation still believes in "something unreachable inside each of us", and that this is mere sentiment: "There's nothing there". "The second Josie won't be a copy", he insists, but Josie herself.

The revelation also changes how we read earlier scenes. The Mother's questions in the store about Josie's eyes and voice, and her request that Klara walk like Josie, now look less like a customer's curiosity than like an audition for a role. Klara's patient study of Josie, which she saw as part of being a good friend, turns out to have been training for a performance. Even Miss Helen's odd remark about seeing the Mother with a figure who looked like Sal, after Sal's death, takes on a darker meaning: the family has tried something like this before. Ishiguro's structure makes the reader complicit, since we, like Klara, have been watching Josie closely without knowing why.

The portrait matters because it tests every major character. The Mother wants to believe him, yet doubts that she could love the copy, especially after an earlier attempt involving Sal failed. The Father hates Capaldi precisely because he fears he is right, and he asks Klara whether she believes in "the human heart". Klara, loyal as ever, agrees to do her best, though she later asks the Mother what would happen if she were to continue Josie - a question that hints at doubts she never fully voices. The portrait exposes the Mother's grief, the Father's doubt and Klara's selflessness at once.

In Part Six Mr Capaldi returns. People have grown hostile to AFs, he says, and he wants to open Klara up to learn how she works. The Mother's refusal protects Klara, and Klara's own final insight answers him. Speaking to Manager in the Yard, she says she has realised that what was special about Josie was not inside her: "It was inside those who loved her". In one sense Capaldi was right - there may be nothing unreachable inside a person - but he was looking in the wrong place. Identity lives in relationships, which no copy can inherit.

Context explains why this debate feels urgent. By 2021 artificial intelligence was advancing rapidly, and people were beginning to imagine computers that could imitate particular people, even the dead. Mr Capaldi represents a purely scientific view of the self as information that can be learned and transferred; the Mother, as he says, belongs to a generation that still clings to older beliefs in a soul or heart. Ishiguro had explored a similar question in Never Let Me Go, where clones' art is examined for proof that they have souls. In Klara and the Sun, the answer comes not from science or art but from love.

The portrait is therefore central. It drives the plot, organises the suspense, focuses the novel's question about human uniqueness and makes possible the moving answer Klara gives at the end.

Explanation

Examine questions reward analysis of why something matters: here the portrait's role in plot, suspense and structure, its testing of the characters, and the philosophical debate Mr Capaldi represents. Link the studio scene to the ending in the Yard, and connect the debate to context such as AI, ideas of the self and Never Let Me Go.

Mark scheme
  1. 40 marks

    Levels of response (40 marks). AO1 (20 marks) and AO4 (20 marks).
    Level 5 (33-40 marks): Assured knowledge and understanding of the text. The response shows assured personal engagement and a perceptive critical style. Understanding of the relationship between text and context is integrated convincingly into the response. Discriminating use of relevant examples in support.
    Level 4 (25-32 marks): Thorough knowledge and understanding of the text. The response shows thorough personal engagement and a sustained critical style. There is a detailed awareness of the relationship between text and context. Use of fully relevant examples in support.
    Level 3 (17-24 marks): Sound knowledge and understanding of the text. The response shows relevant personal engagement and an appropriate critical style. There is relevant comment on the relationship between text and context. Use of clearly relevant examples in support.
    Level 2 (9-16 marks): Some knowledge and understanding of the text. The response is largely narrative with some evidence of personal engagement or critical style. There is some comment on the relationship between text and context. Some use of relevant examples in support.
    Level 1 (1-8 marks): Limited knowledge and understanding of the text. The response is simple with little evidence of personal engagement or critical style. There is little comment on the relationship between text and context. Limited use of relevant examples in support.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid, well-supported points and interpretations). AO1: the 'portrait' is mentioned early - Josie sits for it, Rick finds it strange that she has never been shown it, and Melania distrusts Mr Capaldi; it builds suspense and dramatic irony, since Klara and the reader sense it is not a painting. In Part Four, at the studio, Klara completes a questionnaire about Josie, goes through the Purple Door and finds an artificial Josie, suspended, with an expression Josie never wears; the plan is revealed - if Josie dies, Klara will inhabit it and 'continue' her. Mr Capaldi argues that the old belief in "something unreachable inside each of us" is sentimental - "Our generation still carry the old feelings" - that "There's nothing there", and that "The second Josie won't be a copy". The Mother doubts but agrees; the Father hates Capaldi because he fears he is right, and asks Klara whether she believes in "the human heart". Klara agrees to try, though she later asks the Mother what would happen if she were to continue Josie. In Part Six Mr Capaldi wants to study Klara as hostility to AFs grows; the Mother refuses. Klara's final insight - "It was inside those who loved her" - answers him. Importance: plot (the hidden plan), structure (suspense, revelation), theme (identity, uniqueness, love, grief), character (the Mother's grief, the Father's doubt, Klara's loyalty). AO4: debates about AI and whether a mind could be copied or 'uploaded'; materialist versus humanist views of the self; technology and grief (digital imitations of the dead); Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go (clones and art as proof of a soul); the Mother's generation versus the new science; publication in 2021 amid rapid AI development. Weaker answers retell the studio scene; stronger answers explain how the portrait drives the novel's central question and how the ending answers it.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.