Examine the importance of Mr Capaldi and his 'portrait' of Josie in the novel.
You must consider the context of the novel in your answer.
Model answer
Mr Capaldi appears in only a few scenes, but his 'portrait' of Josie is the hidden engine of the novel. It creates suspense, reveals the true purpose of Klara's purchase, sets out the novel's central philosophical question and prepares for Klara's final answer to it. Without the portrait, Klara and the Sun would be a gentle story about a sick child; with it, it becomes a novel about what makes a person who they are.
Ishiguro builds the portrait slowly. Josie sits for it in the city, Rick finds it strange that she has never been shown it, and Melania Housekeeper privately warns Klara that the man is creepy. Klara reports all this without understanding it, and the reader's unease grows. Earlier hints - the Mother making Klara copy Josie's walk in the store, and asking her to be Josie at Morgan's Falls - suddenly connect. This is Ishiguro's typical method: a narrator who sees everything but understands little, so that the reader assembles the truth before she does.
The revelation in Part Four is one of the novel's most unsettling scenes. Klara is asked to fill in a questionnaire about Josie, then slips through the Purple Door and finds an artificial Josie suspended in the air, almost perfect but wearing an expression Josie never wears. The plan is then explained: if Josie dies, Klara will inhabit this body and 'continue' her. Mr Capaldi defends it with calm conviction. He tells the Mother that their generation still believes in "something unreachable inside each of us", and that this is mere sentiment: "There's nothing there". "The second Josie won't be a copy", he insists, but Josie herself.
The revelation also changes how we read earlier scenes. The Mother's questions in the store about Josie's eyes and voice, and her request that Klara walk like Josie, now look less like a customer's curiosity than like an audition for a role. Klara's patient study of Josie, which she saw as part of being a good friend, turns out to have been training for a performance. Even Miss Helen's odd remark about seeing the Mother with a figure who looked like Sal, after Sal's death, takes on a darker meaning: the family has tried something like this before. Ishiguro's structure makes the reader complicit, since we, like Klara, have been watching Josie closely without knowing why.
The portrait matters because it tests every major character. The Mother wants to believe him, yet doubts that she could love the copy, especially after an earlier attempt involving Sal failed. The Father hates Capaldi precisely because he fears he is right, and he asks Klara whether she believes in "the human heart". Klara, loyal as ever, agrees to do her best, though she later asks the Mother what would happen if she were to continue Josie - a question that hints at doubts she never fully voices. The portrait exposes the Mother's grief, the Father's doubt and Klara's selflessness at once.
In Part Six Mr Capaldi returns. People have grown hostile to AFs, he says, and he wants to open Klara up to learn how she works. The Mother's refusal protects Klara, and Klara's own final insight answers him. Speaking to Manager in the Yard, she says she has realised that what was special about Josie was not inside her: "It was inside those who loved her". In one sense Capaldi was right - there may be nothing unreachable inside a person - but he was looking in the wrong place. Identity lives in relationships, which no copy can inherit.
Context explains why this debate feels urgent. By 2021 artificial intelligence was advancing rapidly, and people were beginning to imagine computers that could imitate particular people, even the dead. Mr Capaldi represents a purely scientific view of the self as information that can be learned and transferred; the Mother, as he says, belongs to a generation that still clings to older beliefs in a soul or heart. Ishiguro had explored a similar question in Never Let Me Go, where clones' art is examined for proof that they have souls. In Klara and the Sun, the answer comes not from science or art but from love.
The portrait is therefore central. It drives the plot, organises the suspense, focuses the novel's question about human uniqueness and makes possible the moving answer Klara gives at the end.