Show how characters in The Joy Luck Club struggle to find their own voices.
You must consider the context of the novel in your answer.
Model answer
Voice is one of the deepest concerns of The Joy Luck Club. Almost every woman in the novel struggles to speak for herself, whether because she has been taught silence, because she lacks the language, or because she cannot find the courage. Tan shows that silence can be inherited, but also that voice can be won and passed on, and the novel itself, built from sixteen first-person stories, gives voice to women whose lives had rarely been heard.
The mothers were raised in a culture that prized female silence. Ying-ying recalls being taught to desire nothing and "to eat my own bitterness", and the lesson shaped her whole life: after her first husband's betrayal she became numb and passive, and in America she allowed Clifford to rename her and to translate her words wrongly. An-mei's mother was even more voiceless; as a concubine she had no power, and her only way to change her daughter's future was through death. Yet that death gave An-mei a voice. She says that on that day she "learned to shout".
Lindo shows that voice can be inward before it is spoken. Trapped in an arranged marriage, she promises herself, "I would never forget myself", and then uses words - an invented dream - to win her freedom. Her lesson to Waverly about "invisible strength" suggests that silence can itself be a form of power, though in the Jong family it becomes a weapon between mother and daughter.
The daughters, though born in a freer society, struggle in different ways. Rose is so passive in her marriage that Ted accuses her of never making decisions, and when he asks for a divorce she cannot fight. An-mei, who knows the cost of silence, urges her to speak, and Rose finally does, refusing to give up the house and telling Ted that he cannot just "pull me out of your life". She describes the effect with surprise: "The power of my words was that strong." Lena, by contrast, accepts Harold's unfair balance sheet without protest, and only her mother's question about the broken vase hints that she might one day speak. Jing-mei's struggle is with her mother's expectations; she declares, "I won't be what I'm not", but only after Suyuan's death does she find her true voice, when she must tell her mother's story to her sisters.
Language itself is a barrier. The mothers' English is limited and the daughters' Chinese is weak, so love and wisdom are lost in translation. The old woman in the opening parable keeps her swan's feather for years, waiting until she can explain it in perfect American English. Ying-ying finally decides to break her silence and "cut her tiger spirit loose" in Lena, choosing to speak in her own way rather than wait for the right words.
When ordinary language fails, the characters improvise. Lindo and Tin Jong, who speak different Chinese dialects, communicate at first in broken English and through the messages in fortune cookies, on An-mei's advice. The episode is gently comic, but it shows how immigrants build a voice from whatever words are available, and how love can be expressed even without a shared language. It also suggests that the problem in the mother-daughter relationships is not only vocabulary but listening: the daughters can understand their mothers' English perfectly well, yet they often do not hear what their mothers mean.
The context explains why voice matters so much. In early twentieth-century China, women were expected to obey fathers, husbands and mothers-in-law, and concubines and widows had almost no rights. Immigration to America brought new freedoms but also new silences, as women without fluent English depended on husbands and children. By the 1980s, when Tan was writing, the women's movement had made the idea of women finding their voice central to American culture, and writers such as Maxine Hong Kingston had begun to tell Chinese American women's stories. Tan has spoken of wanting to record her mother's and grandmother's experiences, and the novel can be read as her own act of giving them a voice.
In conclusion, Tan shows that voice is hard won. The mothers find it through suffering and pass it on through their stories; the daughters must learn to use it in their own lives. The novel's structure, in which each woman speaks for herself, suggests that telling one's story is the first step towards being understood.