Re-read My Last Duchess and Half-caste in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present attitudes towards other people in My Last Duchess and Half-caste.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
My Last Duchess and Half-caste both present a speaker addressing a listener who never replies, and in both the speaker's attitudes towards other people are revealed through his voice. Browning's Duke looks down on almost everyone - his late wife, the men who pleased her, even the envoy he flatters - while Agard's speaker turns the tables on a listener who looks down on him. The Duke's attitudes condemn him; Agard's speaker exposes the prejudice of others.
Both poems use direct address to a silent listener. The Duke courteously directs his guest - "Will't please you sit and look at her?" - and the envoy's silence lets the Duke's voice dominate. Agard's speaker is confrontational from the start, repeating the demand "Explain yuself" and the challenge "wha yu mean". The phonetic spelling of Caribbean speech asserts the speaker's own voice and identity, while the imperatives put the listener on the defensive. The Duke's politeness hides control; Agard's bluntness is open and honest.
The speakers' attitudes to difference are opposed. The Duke resents that his wife did not discriminate: "she liked whate'er / She looked on, and her looks went everywhere", and she ranked his "gift of a nine-hundred-years-old name / With anybody's gift". He believes that people should be valued according to rank and birth, and he dismisses the man who brought her cherries as "some officious fool". Agard's speaker attacks exactly this kind of thinking. He mocks the idea that someone of mixed race is only half a person, using examples of mixing that everyone admires: Picasso blending colours on a canvas, English weather mixing light and shadow, and Tchaikovsky writing for the black and white keys of a piano. If mixing makes these things great, the term is absurd. Where the Duke ranks people, Agard's speaker insists on a shared humanity: he is a "half-caste human being".
Humour and irony shape both poems, but differently. Agard's humour is deliberate: he imagines himself looking with "half-a-eye" and dreaming only half a dream, exaggerating the insult until it collapses. The joke turns back on the listener, whose thinking is the thing that is really incomplete. The Duke's irony is unintended. He claims to lack skill "In speech" - "which I have not", he adds - while speaking with great fluency, and he condemns his wife's kindness - "She thanked men" - in a way that makes the reader sympathise with her. His contempt for others shows more clearly than he realises.
Both speakers judge another person, but the consequences differ. The Duke never tells his wife what displeases him, because he chooses "Never to stoop"; instead, "I gave commands; / Then all smiles stopped together." His contempt ends in her death or silencing, and he moves on calmly to the "dowry" for his next marriage. Agard's speaker wants to be understood. His ending invites the listener to come back with a whole eye and a whole mind, and then "I will tell yu" "de other half" of his story. The Duke silences the person he judged; Agard's speaker refuses to be silenced and offers dialogue.
Form and structure reflect these attitudes. Browning writes in rhyming couplets of iambic pentameter, a formal, controlled pattern that matches the Duke's aristocratic manner, though enjambment makes it sound like natural speech. Agard writes in free verse, with little conventional punctuation, short lines and non-standard spelling, rejecting the 'standard' rules just as he rejects the standard insult. The Duke's monologue is one continuous verse paragraph in which he never pauses for a reply; Agard's poem moves from the listener's prejudice to the speaker's own invitation, so its structure opens up a conversation.
In conclusion, both poets use a speaking voice to reveal attitudes towards others. Browning lets an arrogant aristocrat expose his own contempt and cruelty, while Agard gives a voice to someone on the receiving end of contempt, who answers it with wit and challenges the listener to see him whole.
Explanation
Both poems are spoken to a silent listener, so compare how each voice reveals attitudes: the Duke's polished contempt (exposed through dramatic irony) and Agard's witty challenge to prejudice. Compare address, attitudes to difference, humour and irony, consequences and form. Half-caste is printed in the exam paper, so quote short phrases precisely and describe its examples (Picasso, the weather, Tchaikovsky) in your own words.