Re-read La Belle Dame sans Merci in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present women in La Belle Dame sans Merci and one other poem from the anthology.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
La Belle Dame sans Merci and My Last Duchess both present a woman who is no longer present, described entirely by a man. In both, the woman's own thoughts are hidden from us, and the reader must look past the male speaker to understand her. But the two women occupy opposite positions of power: Keats's lady holds the knight "in thrall", while Browning's Duchess was controlled, and finally destroyed, by her husband.
Both women are filtered through a male voice. Keats's lady is described only by the knight, and her one recorded sentence, "I love thee true", was spoken "in language strange", so even her words are uncertain. Browning's Duchess never speaks at all: we hear only the Duke, talking to the envoy of the Count whose daughter he means to marry. Both poets therefore make the reader question the speaker. The knight is bewildered and may have misunderstood the lady; the Duke is arrogant and reveals more than he intends.
Both men are disturbed by a woman's eyes and looks. The knight notices first that "her eyes were wild", and later he shuts "her wild wild eyes / With kisses four": the repetition suggests that her untamed nature fascinates and frightens him. The Duke resents his wife's glance in a different way: she had "A heart ... too soon made glad", "she liked whate'er / She looked on, and her looks went everywhere." To the Duke, her cheerful, open gaze was an insult to his status. Keats's lady seems dangerous because she is wild; Browning's Duchess seems innocent, but her freedom is what the Duke could not bear.
Power is the clearest contrast. The pale kings and princes of the knight's dream cry that "La Belle Dame sans Merci / Thee hath in thrall!": the lady is a femme fatale who has enslaved great men. In My Last Duchess power belongs entirely to the man. "I gave commands; / Then all smiles stopped together" is the chilling statement of a husband who could end his wife's life with an order. Even in death she is under his control: she is "painted on the wall", and no one draws "The curtain I have drawn for you, but I".
Yet both women can be read with sympathy. Keats's lady "wept and sighed full sore" in her grot, which suggests sorrow or even pity, and some readers see her as a lonely figure who is blamed for the knight's weakness. Browning's Duchess is clearly a victim: her kindness to everyone, even the busybody who broke off a bough of cherries for her, is presented through the Duke's contempt, but the reader admires her. In both poems, then, a woman's independence or difference provokes a man's fear or anger.
Form shapes these portraits. Keats's ballad tells the story through two male voices, the questioner and the knight, and its circular structure leaves the knight trapped, so the lady remains a mystery. Browning's dramatic monologue lets the Duke speak continuously in rhyming couplets whose enjambment makes his speech sound smooth and casual, and dramatic irony lets us see the cruelty beneath his charm. The poem ends with him pointing out a statue of Neptune "Taming a sea-horse", an image of male domination that sums up his view of women.
In conclusion, both poets show women seen through the eyes of men who cannot understand or tolerate them. Keats presents a woman whose power over men is mysterious and frightening; Browning presents a woman whose lack of power is tragic. Read together, the poems invite us to ask whether the danger lies in the women, or in the men who describe them.
Explanation
With 'one other poem' questions, choose a partner in which a woman is central; My Last Duchess works well because both women are seen only through a man's account. Compare voice, power, the presentation of the women's eyes and behaviour, and possible sympathetic or feminist readings, analysing both poems in each paragraph. Avoid simply describing each woman.