Re-read Poem at Thirty-Nine and Sonnet 116 in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present lasting love in Poem at Thirty-Nine and Sonnet 116.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Sonnet 116 and Poem at Thirty-Nine both present love that survives what might destroy it. Shakespeare defines ideal love as constant, unchanged by time, difficulty or even death; Walker shows a daughter's love for her father enduring beyond his death and beyond the conflicts of their relationship. Shakespeare argues in general terms, while Walker proves her case through personal memory.
Shakespeare begins by defining love through what it is not: "Love is not love / Which alters when it alteration finds". The wordplay on "alters" and "alteration" insists that true love does not change when circumstances do. Walker's poem shows this kind of love in practice. Her relationship with her father was not always easy: she admits that "telling the truth" did not always mean "a beating", and that many of her truths "grieved him". Yet her love survives these difficulties: she remembers his strictness and the hurt she caused without bitterness. Walker's love is convincing because it has been tested.
Both poets present love as something that withstands time and death. Shakespeare declares, "Love's not Time's fool, though rosy lips and cheeks / Within his bending sickle's compass come": Time is personified as a reaper who can destroy beauty but not love, which "bears it out even to the edge of doom". Walker's father has already died, yet the poem opens with, and later returns to, the same cry: "How I miss my father". The repetition, the second time with an exclamation mark, shows that her love has not faded: at thirty-nine, decades after her childhood, it is stronger, not weaker.
The poets use imagery of fixed points and guidance. For Shakespeare, love is "an ever-fixed mark / That looks on tempests and is never shaken" and "the star to every wandering bark", a guiding light for lost ships. Walker's father is also a guide: his lessons about "deposit slips and checks" taught her to see "bits of paper" as a means of "escape", steering her away from the hard life he knew. Shakespeare's guiding star is an abstract ideal; Walker's guide is a tired, ordinary man whose love took practical form.
In Walker's poem, love endures by becoming part of the person who loves. She now cooks "just like him", and his joy in cooking, like someone "dancing / in a yoga meditation", lives on in her own generous kitchen. The father's way of loving has been passed on, so it cannot be lost. Shakespeare's love endures by remaining constant in itself; Walker's endures by being inherited.
Form and structure reflect these approaches. Sonnet 116 is a Shakespearean sonnet of three quatrains and a couplet in iambic pentameter, a disciplined form that mirrors the steadiness it praises. The final couplet, "If this be error and upon me proved, / I never writ, nor no man ever loved", stakes the poet's reputation on his claim, like a confident legal challenge. Walker's free verse is loose and conversational, with short lines that let memories surface one by one, and it moves from past to present as love turns into resemblance. Shakespeare argues; Walker remembers.
Both poems end with confidence. Shakespeare's couplet insists that his definition cannot be disproved. Walker imagines that her father would have come to admire "the woman I've become", a confident statement of her identity and of their bond. Her final image of "staring into the fire" is quieter, suggesting reflection and the warmth that remains.
In conclusion, both poets present love as constant despite change, conflict and death. Shakespeare presents it as a timeless ideal in a perfectly controlled sonnet, while Walker shows it surviving in the specific, imperfect bond between a daughter and her father, carried forward in the way she lives.