Re-read War Photographer and My Last Duchess in your anthology.
Compare how the writers present the power of images in War Photographer and My Last Duchess.
You should make reference to language, form and structure.
Support your answer with examples from the poems.
Model answer
Both War Photographer and My Last Duchess are about images of people who are dead or suffering - war photographs and a portrait - and both explore who controls such images and what power they hold over those who look at them. However, Browning's Duke uses an image to possess and silence, whereas Duffy's photographer is haunted by the images he makes, and the public is barely moved by them.
In both poems an image preserves the dead. Browning's monologue opens with the portrait "Looking as if she were alive", and returns to the idea near the end: "There she stands / As if alive". The painting has outlived the Duchess, and its lifelike quality is unsettling, since the Duke appears to be responsible for her death. Duffy's photographs also bring back the dead: as an image develops, a dying man reappears as "a half-formed ghost". The metaphor captures the faint, incomplete image while suggesting that the dead man haunts the photographer. In both poems, images are a kind of afterlife.
The poems differ in how the images affect their makers and owners. Duffy's photographer is shaken by his own pictures: his hands "did not tremble then" in the war zones, but now, in the darkroom, they appear to shake. His films are "spools of suffering", and he treats them with reverence, as if "this were a church". Browning's Duke, by contrast, shows no guilt. He resented the Duchess's warmth - the "spot / Of joy" in her cheek and her readiness to smile at everyone - and his chilling statement "I gave commands; / Then all smiles stopped together" reduces her death to a single cold sentence. The Duke prefers the image to the woman, because the image can be controlled.
Control over images is central to both poems. The Duke keeps the portrait behind a curtain: "The curtain I have drawn for you, but I". Only he decides who may see her, so the painting becomes a possession, like the bronze Neptune "Taming a sea-horse" that Claus of Innsbruck "cast in bronze for me". A god taming an animal hints at how the Duke sees his role in marriage. In War Photographer the control belongs to the media. Of "A hundred agonies", the editor will choose only a handful for the Sunday supplement, so most of the suffering is never seen, and what is shown is chosen for a weekend magazine. Both poets suggest that whoever controls an image controls how its subject is remembered.
Both poems also include viewers. The Duke's listener, the envoy, is invited to "sit and look at her", and through him the reader becomes a viewer of the portrait too, drawn into the Duke's version of events. Duffy's viewers are the Sunday readers, whose eyes sting with tears only between their bath and their "pre-lunch beers". The internal rhyme of tears and beers makes their sympathy sound trivial, and the poem ends bluntly: "they do not care". The Duchess's painted glance, the Duke says, makes strangers want to ask how it came there; Duffy's photographs, though they show real agony, cannot hold their readers' attention.
Images and money are linked in both poems. The Duke shows the portrait while negotiating a dowry for his next marriage, so his last wife's image becomes part of the bargaining for a new one. Duffy's photographer makes his living from images of suffering, and the newspaper sells them. Both poets expose how images of people, even of victims, can become commodities.
Form reinforces these ideas. Browning's dramatic monologue is written in rhyming couplets of iambic pentameter, but heavy enjambment makes the Duke sound casual and conversational, hiding a ruthless control beneath the surface. Duffy's regular six-line stanzas, each ending in a rhyming couplet, mirror the photographer's neat rows of film: a calm surface over terrible content. In both poems an orderly form frames something disturbing, just as the curtain frames the portrait.
In the end, both poems ask the reader to look carefully at images and at those who control them. Browning reveals a man who turned a living woman into a possession on a wall; Duffy reveals a society that turns real suffering into a few pictures to glance at on a Sunday. Both make the reader uncomfortably aware of the power, and the moral responsibility, of looking.
Explanation
The focus asks what images can do: preserve the dead, haunt, provoke, be controlled, be sold, or be ignored. Compare the makers and owners of images (photographer, editor, Duke), the viewers (readers, envoy, us) and the forms that frame them. The commonest weakness is describing the photographs and the portrait instead of analysing how each poet presents their power.