Question 1
1 markIn four experiments, the same membrane separated two solutions of the same solute. Only the concentrations of the solutions were different.
Which pair of concentrations, in arbitrary units, would give the fastest rate of diffusion of the solute across the membrane?
Choose your answer.
- A 50 and 40
- B 90 and 80
- C 60 and 45
- D 30 and 5
Model answer
D - 30 and 5 (concentration difference of 25 arbitrary units).
Explanation
The rate of diffusion depends on the concentration difference (the steepness of the concentration gradient), not on how high the concentrations are. The pair 30 and 5 has the biggest difference, 25 units. Choosing B, because it has the highest concentrations, is the common misconception.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
D / 30 and 5 (1)
The only correct answer is D: the rate depends on the concentration difference across the membrane, and 30 − 5 = 25 is the largest difference. A is not correct because the difference is only 50 − 40 = 10; B is not correct because, although these are the highest concentrations, the difference is only 90 − 80 = 10; C is not correct because the difference is 60 − 45 = 15, smaller than 25. Accept the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.