'Religious believers should not eat meat.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some religious believers would strongly agree. Many Hindus are vegetarian because of ahimsa, the principle of non-violence, and the belief that every animal has an atman; the Laws of Manu say that meat 'can never be obtained without injury to living creatures' and so should be avoided (Manu 5.48). Many Buddhists, especially in Mahayana traditions, are vegetarian because the first precept forbids harming living beings and because compassion should extend to all creatures. Sikh langar is always vegetarian so that everyone can eat together, and many Sikhs choose not to eat meat at all. Some Christians point out that in Genesis 1:29 God originally gave humans plants to eat, and they argue that factory farming, which can keep animals in cramped conditions, goes against stewardship. There are also environmental reasons: livestock farming uses large amounts of land and adds to greenhouse gas emissions, so eating less meat helps to protect God's creation.
On the other hand, most Christians, Muslims and Jews believe eating meat is allowed. After the flood God told Noah, 'Every moving thing that liveth shall be meat for you' (Genesis 9:3), Jesus ate fish, and in Acts 10 Peter is told not to call anything unclean that God has made clean. Muslims may eat halal meat, and at Eid al-Adha many share the meat of a sacrificed animal (qurbani) with the poor, while Jews may eat kosher meat, for example at Shabbat and festival meals. Theravada Buddhist monks may accept meat given as alms if the animal was not killed specially for them, and Guru Nanak criticised people who argue over meat while ignoring more important matters (Guru Granth Sahib 1289). These believers argue that what matters is treating animals humanely and slaughtering them with as little suffering as possible.
Non-religious people also disagree with each other: some become vegetarian or vegan for animal welfare or environmental reasons, while others argue that meat from well-treated animals is a natural and healthy part of the human diet.
In conclusion, I disagree that religious believers in general should not eat meat, because several major religions clearly permit it and their scriptures give humans permission to do so. However, the arguments about animal suffering and the environment are strong, so I think religious believers should at least eat less meat and choose meat from animals that have been well treated.
Explanation
Top answers show the genuine diversity within and between religions, for example Mahayana and Theravada Buddhist practice, or Hindus who eat meat, rather than treating each religion as one view. Apply teachings such as Genesis 9:3, ahimsa and the langar directly to the statement. The conclusion should weigh the religious permissions against the welfare and environmental arguments rather than repeat them.