'A woman should always have the right to choose whether to have an abortion.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many people would agree with this statement. Pro-choice supporters argue that a woman has the right to make decisions about her own body, and that she is the person most affected by pregnancy, birth and bringing up a child. They point out that when abortion is illegal, some women turn to unsafe abortions that put their lives at risk. Humanists support a woman's right to choose and campaigned for the change in the law in 2026, which means a woman in England and Wales no longer commits a criminal offence by ending her own pregnancy. Some liberal Christians and Reform Jews also believe that God gave humans free will and conscience, so the woman, after careful thought and advice, should make the final decision. Some Buddhists stress that the intention behind an action is what matters, so a compassionate decision made by the woman may be right.
However, many people disagree, especially with the word 'always'. The Catholic Church teaches that life must be protected from the moment of conception (CCC 2270), so the unborn child also has a right to life which no one else can take away: 'Thou shalt not kill' (Exodus 20:13). Many Muslims believe the soul is breathed into the foetus at 120 days, after which abortion is allowed only to save the mother's life, and Islam teaches that life belongs to Allah, not to the individual. Many Hindus and Sikhs believe life is sacred and that abortion breaks ahimsa or interferes with God's creation, and Sikh teaching strongly condemns the abortion of baby girls because of their sex, which shows that unlimited choice can be misused. Even UK law does not give an unlimited right: under the Abortion Act 1967 two doctors must agree, and the usual limit is 24 weeks. Some people also argue that the father's views should be considered.
In conclusion, I disagree that a woman should always have the right to choose. A woman's own life, health and choices are very important, and she should play the central part in the decision. However, the word 'always' ignores the unborn child, whose claim to protection grows stronger as the pregnancy develops, so I think the right to choose should have limits, as the law already recognises.
Explanation
Focus on the word 'always': strong answers consider whether the right to choose should have limits, such as later in pregnancy. Include religious arguments on both sides (for example liberal views on conscience and Catholic or Muslim teaching on the unborn child) and accurate UK law. Treat the issue factually and respectfully, recognising that people on both sides hold their views sincerely.