'Pacifism cannot be right when innocent people are being attacked.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many religious believers agree with this statement. Christians are commanded to love their neighbour, and many argue that standing by while innocent people are killed is a failure of love. The Catholic Church teaches that legitimate defence can be a grave duty for those responsible for others (CCC 2265), and Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a Lutheran pastor with pacifist sympathies, decided that resisting Hitler was less evil than doing nothing. The Torah commands 'neither shalt thou stand against the blood of thy neighbour' (Leviticus 19:16), which Jews understand as a duty not to stand by when someone's life is in danger. The Qur'an asks why believers will not fight for 'the feeble among men and of the women and the children' (Qur'an 4:75), and Sikhs are taught to be saint-soldiers who defend the weak.
However, pacifists argue that their position is not about doing nothing. Quakers believe they must follow Jesus, who told Peter to put away his sword (Matthew 26:52), but they help victims, for example through the Friends Ambulance Unit in both World Wars, and work to end conflicts through mediation. Pacifists point out that war usually creates more innocent victims than it saves, especially with modern weapons. Non-violent action can also protect people: during the Second World War the Protestant village of Le Chambon-sur-Lignon in France sheltered thousands of Jews without using violence. Buddhists who keep the first precept and Hindus who follow ahimsa believe killing can never bring real peace, because 'hatred does not cease by hatred' (Dhammapada 5).
Non-religious views are divided too. Some humanists support military action to protect civilians from mass killing, which the United Nations accepted in 2005 as the 'responsibility to protect', while others, like Bertrand Russell in the First World War, have been pacifists.
In conclusion, I largely agree with the statement. Pacifists show great courage, and non-violent methods can save lives, as Le Chambon shows. However, when innocent people face mass murder and peaceful methods have failed, refusing to use any force can leave the vulnerable unprotected. Pacifism can still be right as a personal commitment for those who serve in other ways, so it is not simply wrong, but it cannot be the only right response.
Explanation
High-level answers show that pacifism is more than 'doing nothing' and weigh it fairly against the duty to protect the innocent, using teachings such as Leviticus 19:16, Qur'an 4:75 and Matthew 26:52. Real examples, such as Bonhoeffer or Le Chambon, strengthen the reasoning. Avoid stereotypes such as describing pacifists as cowards, and make the conclusion follow from the arguments.