'Some crimes are too terrible to forgive.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people, including some religious believers, agree that certain crimes are too terrible to forgive. Crimes such as murder, terrorism or the abuse of children cause such deep and lasting harm that forgiving them might seem to make light of the victims' suffering. Many Jews believe that only the person who has been wronged can forgive, because the Mishnah teaches that wrongs against another person are not atoned for until that person has been appeased (Mishnah Yoma 8:9). This means no one else can forgive a murder on the victim's behalf. In his book The Sunflower, the Jewish writer Simon Wiesenthal describes how, as a prisoner in a Nazi concentration camp, he could not bring himself to forgive a dying SS soldier for crimes committed against other Jews. Some believers also argue that forgiving an offender who shows no remorse is unjust, since Jesus linked forgiveness to repentance in Luke 17:3.
However, many religious believers argue that no crime is beyond forgiveness. Jesus told Peter to forgive 'until seventy times seven' (Matthew 18:22), meaning without limit, and on the cross he prayed for the people who were crucifying him (Luke 23:34). Christians such as Gee Walker, whose son Anthony was murdered in a racist attack in 2005, have forgiven terrible crimes. The Qur'an teaches that God 'forgiveth all sins' for those who turn to him (Qur'an 39:53), and Islamic law allows the family of a murder victim to forgive the killer (Qur'an 2:178). Buddhists believe that hatred never ends through hatred (Dhammapada 5), and the story of Angulimala shows that even a murderer can change. These believers stress that forgiveness does not mean excusing the crime or cancelling the punishment; it means refusing to let hatred win.
Non-religious people also hold different views. Humanists see forgiveness as a personal choice: some victims find that it helps them heal, while others feel some crimes cannot be forgiven, and both responses deserve respect.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Some crimes are so terrible that forgiveness may take many years, and no victim should be pressured to forgive. But the examples of people like Gee Walker show that forgiveness is possible even after the worst crimes, and because forgiveness is different from excusing a crime or removing justice, I do not think any crime is truly too terrible to forgive.
Explanation
Top answers weigh the seriousness of crimes and the Jewish teaching that only victims can forgive against teachings that forgiveness has no limit, using real examples such as Gee Walker accurately. Distinguishing forgiveness from excusing a crime or removing punishment is often what lifts an answer to the top level. Make sure the conclusion follows from the arguments rather than simply repeating them.