'A loving God would not allow innocent people to suffer.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many people agree with this statement. The problem of evil, which Hume set out using an argument he attributed to Epicurus, says that if God is all-loving he would want to stop suffering, if he is all-powerful he could stop it, and if he is all-knowing he would know about it. Yet innocent people still suffer: babies are born with painful diseases and thousands of people die in earthquakes and tsunamis through no fault of their own. Free will cannot explain this natural evil, because no human chose it. Atheists argue that the world looks exactly as we would expect if there were no loving God, and even some religious people have struggled to keep their faith after great suffering; the Jewish writer Elie Wiesel described how his faith was shaken by the Holocaust. Humanists would say that, rather than looking for a reason in God, people should work together to reduce suffering through medicine, science and compassion.
However, most religious believers argue that a loving God can allow suffering for good reasons. Christians believe God gave humans free will so that they can freely choose to love and do good; Genesis 3 teaches that suffering entered the world through human disobedience, and much innocent suffering today is caused by human choices such as war and greed. Irenaeus and John Hick argued that a world with challenges is a place of soul-making, where people can develop courage, compassion and patience, just as loving parents allow their children to face difficulties. Christians also believe that God shares in innocent suffering, because Jesus, who was innocent, suffered and died on the cross, and that God will one day 'wipe away all tears' (Revelation 21:4). Muslims believe suffering is a test from Allah (Qur'an 2:155) and that those who are patient will be rewarded. Hindus and Sikhs may see suffering as linked to karma from past actions, so it is not random, while Buddhists do not believe in an all-loving creator, so for them the question does not arise in the same way.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement, although it raises a very serious problem. The free will and soul-making arguments show that a loving God might allow some suffering for a greater good. However, these explanations are weaker for extreme natural evil, such as young children dying of disease, so I can understand why many people find the problem of evil the strongest argument against God.
Explanation
Top-level answers explain the problem of evil clearly, then weigh religious responses such as free will, soul-making, a test of faith or karma against it, focusing on the word 'innocent'. Religious teaching, such as Genesis 3, Qur'an 2:155 or Revelation 21:4, should be applied to the argument rather than just quoted. Make sure the conclusion follows from the arguments, for example by judging whether the theodicies work for natural evil.