'Reconciliation is more important than justice after a conflict.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some religious believers agree that reconciliation is more important than justice after a conflict. In South Africa after apartheid, Archbishop Desmond Tutu chaired the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which offered amnesty to people who told the full truth about politically motivated crimes. Tutu believed that punishing everyone would leave the country divided, while truth and forgiveness could heal it, and he called his book No Future Without Forgiveness. Christians believe God has given them 'the ministry of reconciliation' (2 Corinthians 5:18). In Northern Ireland, the Good Friday Agreement of 1998 included the early release of paramilitary prisoners, which many people found painful, but it helped to end thirty years of violence. Muslims also value reconciliation, as the Qur'an says 'make peace between your brethren' (Qur'an 49:10).
On the other hand, many believers argue that reconciliation without justice is not real peace. Pope Paul VI taught 'If you want peace, work for justice', and the Qur'an commands Muslims to make peace between groups 'justly' (Qur'an 49:9). Victims may feel betrayed if those who harmed them go unpunished: in South Africa some victims' families, including the family of Steve Biko, challenged the amnesty in court. Jews believe repentance includes putting right the harm done, and the Torah says 'Justice, justice shalt thou follow' (Deuteronomy 16:20). Without justice, resentment may grow and conflict may start again.
Humanists would weigh the consequences: if a reconciliation process saves lives and lets people live together, it may be worth accepting less punishment, but human rights mean that victims deserve the truth and some form of accountability.
In conclusion, I do not think reconciliation is more important than justice, because the two depend on each other. Reconciliation built on lies or ignored suffering does not last, but justice that only punishes can keep old hatreds alive. The best approach is restorative justice, as in South Africa, where the truth had to be told before amnesty was given: this combines justice and reconciliation rather than choosing one over the other.
Explanation
High-level answers use real examples, such as South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission or Northern Ireland, and apply religious teaching on both reconciliation and justice. The conclusion should weigh the two sides, and arguing that they cannot be separated is a valid judgement if it is explained. A common weakness is to define the two words without evaluating which matters more.