'Visions are only the product of a person's imagination.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Atheists and Humanists would agree with this statement. They argue that visions can be explained by the way the human brain works. Dreams, hallucinations, high fevers, drugs, lack of sleep or food, and conditions such as epilepsy can all make people see and hear things that are not really there. It is striking that people usually see figures from their own religion: Catholics tend to see the Virgin Mary, while Hindus may see Krishna, which suggests that the vision comes from what the person already believes. Visions also cannot be tested or repeated, and they are often seen by only one person; when Bernadette saw the lady at Lourdes, the people around her saw nothing. Some people have also lied about visions to gain attention or money. Even some Christians are cautious, believing that the Bible contains all the revelation that is needed.
However, many Christians believe God can genuinely reveal himself through visions. The Bible records many examples: Isaiah saw God in the Temple (Isaiah 6), and Saul saw a light and heard the risen Jesus on the road to Damascus (Acts 9). Saul's vision transformed him from a persecutor of Christians into Paul, the Church's greatest missionary, and believers argue that imagination alone is unlikely to cause such a complete and lasting change. The Catholic Church investigates claimed visions carefully and rejects many of them, so those it recognises, such as Lourdes, have survived serious scrutiny. Catholics also point out that Bernadette reported the lady calling herself 'the Immaculate Conception', a term they believe she did not understand. Jesus taught 'Ye shall know them by their fruits' (Matthew 7:16), and the good results of many visions, such as lives of prayer and service, suggest they are genuine. Muslims believe Muhammad's experience in the cave of Hira gave the Qur'an, and Sikhs believe Guru Nanak received God's message at the River Bein. Some believers add that even if the brain is involved in a vision, God could be working through it.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement, because the word 'only' is too strong. It is likely that some visions are caused by illness, expectation or imagination, and they should be tested carefully. However, the lasting effects of visions like Saul's, and the careful investigation of some modern claims, mean we cannot be sure that every vision comes from the imagination alone.
Explanation
Top answers weigh natural explanations of visions against religious arguments, using specific examples such as Saul, Isaiah, Bernadette or Muhammad, and focus on the word 'only'. Apply religious teaching, such as Matthew 7:16 on judging by results, rather than simply retelling a vision. A common weakness is to describe visions without evaluating whether imagination can explain them all.