'General revelation is a more reliable source of knowledge about God than special revelation.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many people would agree with this statement. General revelation, through nature, scripture, conscience and worship, is open to everyone and can be shared and discussed by many people, so it is less likely to be one person's mistake. Special revelation, such as a vision, happens to only a few people and cannot be tested by anyone else; it could be a hallucination, a dream, the result of illness, or even a deliberate lie. Even the Catholic Church rejects many claimed visions and teaches that private revelations are not necessary for faith (Catechism 67). Paul writes in Romans 1:20 that God's power can be clearly seen in creation, which suggests that God intended general revelation to be available to all. Scripture is also public and stable: Muslims believe the Qur'an has not been changed, and Sikhs treat the Guru Granth Sahib as their eternal Guru.
However, others argue that general revelation is actually less reliable. Nature is open to many interpretations: it contains suffering as well as beauty, and atheists and Humanists look at the same world and see no God at all. At most, nature might show that a creator exists, but it cannot tell us what God is like or what God wants; the Catechism teaches that there is an order of knowledge that only revelation can give (Catechism 50). Scripture, which counts as general revelation, itself comes from special revelation: Muslims believe the Qur'an was revealed to Muhammad through the angel Jibril, Jews believe the Torah was given to Moses at Sinai, and Christians believe God was revealed most fully in Jesus (Hebrews 1:1-2). Someone who receives a special revelation may also be completely certain of it, as Saul was on the road to Damascus. Many believers would say the two work together rather than compete.
In conclusion, I partly agree with the statement. General revelation is more reliable in the sense that it is public and can be shared, whereas individual visions are hard to check. However, general revelation gives only a vague idea of God, and the most trusted sources of knowledge about God, the scriptures, depend on special revelation in the first place. So general revelation is a safer starting point, but it is not a more reliable source on its own.
Explanation
Strong answers think carefully about what 'reliable' means, for example whether a source can be checked by others or whether it gives clear knowledge of God. Use examples and teachings from both sides, such as Romans 1:20 and Catechism 67 against Catechism 50 and the revelation of the Qur'an. A common pitfall is to define general and special revelation without evaluating which is more reliable.