'Same-sex parents can give children just as good a family life as other parents.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many people would agree with this statement. What children need most is love, stability, safety and encouragement, and two mothers or two fathers can provide these just as well as a mother and a father. Many research studies have found that children brought up by same-sex parents do as well as other children. In England and Wales, same-sex couples have been able to adopt jointly since 2005, and many children in care have found loving homes in this way. Many Christians, including Quakers, Methodists and many Anglicans, support same-sex parents, believing that 'God is love' (1 John 4:8) and that a home filled with love reflects God's will. Liberal and Reform Jews welcome same-sex families fully, and many Buddhists would say that what matters is metta (loving-kindness) and care, not the sex of the parents. Humanists would agree that the quality of parenting is what counts.
However, other believers disagree. The Catholic Church teaches that a family is 'a man and a woman united in marriage, together with their children' (CCC 2202) and that a child has a right to be born of a father and mother bound to each other by marriage (CCC 2376). Catholics and many evangelical Christians believe that God created humans 'male and female' (Genesis 1:27) to complement each other, so children benefit from both a male and a female parent as role models. Most Muslims, Orthodox Jews and many Sikhs share the belief that the family should be based on the marriage of a man and a woman. Some of these believers also question whether research has yet studied enough families over a long enough time. It is important to note that these traditions still teach that the children of same-sex couples must be treated with love and respect; the Catholic Church, for example, may baptise them.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement. The arguments against it rest on a particular religious view of the family, which deserves respect but is not shared by all believers. Many single parents, grandparents and step-parents bring up children successfully without both a mother and a father in the home, which suggests that love, stability and commitment matter more than the sex of the parents. On this basis, same-sex parents can give children just as good a family life as other parents.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh the importance of love and stability against religious beliefs about the complementarity of mothers and fathers, applying sources such as CCC 2202 or 1 John 4:8. Keep the focus on family life for children rather than on same-sex relationships in general. All views should be expressed respectfully, and either conclusion can reach the top level if it is justified by the arguments.