'Life imprisonment is a better punishment for murder than the death penalty.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many religious believers agree that life imprisonment is a better punishment for murder than the death penalty. Life imprisonment protects the public just as effectively, because the murderer cannot kill again, and the Catholic Catechism points out that 'more effective systems of detention' now protect citizens without killing anyone (CCC 2267). Prison also allows mistakes to be corrected. Timothy Evans was hanged in 1950 for a murder he did not commit and was pardoned in 1966, but nothing could bring him back. Life imprisonment leaves room for repentance and reform: God has 'no pleasure in the death of the wicked' (Ezekiel 33:11), and the penitent thief turned to Jesus even as he was dying. Buddhists point to Angulimala, a murderer who became a monk, and Sikhs to Sajjan, a robber who changed after meeting Guru Nanak. Most Christian denominations in Britain, and many Buddhists, Hindus and Sikhs, therefore believe imprisonment is the better choice.
However, some religious believers argue that death is the only just punishment for murder. The Torah teaches 'life for life' (Exodus 21:23), and Genesis 9:6 says that whoever sheds human blood should have his own blood shed, because humans are made in God's image. Many Muslims believe a Shari'ah court may impose qisas for murder, and the Qur'an says 'there is life for you in retaliation' (Qur'an 2:179), suggesting it protects society by deterring killing, although the victim's family may choose to forgive. Others point out that life imprisonment is expensive and may not feel like justice to victims' families. Pope Francis even called a life sentence 'a secret death penalty' (Fratelli Tutti 268), warning that prison without any hope can also deny human dignity.
Non-religious views are also divided. Most Humanists oppose the death penalty because it violates the right to life and cannot be reversed, while some people support it for the worst murders as retribution.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement. Both punishments take murder seriously, but only life imprisonment allows a wrongful conviction to be corrected and gives the offender a chance to repent. Since prison protects the public just as well, there is no need to take another life, as long as prisons keep the hope of rehabilitation that Pope Francis called for.
Explanation
Top-level answers compare the two punishments directly, using the aims of punishment and applying teachings such as Ezekiel 33:11, Genesis 9:6 or Qur'an 2:178 to each side. Accurate examples of miscarriages of justice, such as Timothy Evans, strengthen the argument when they are explained. Make sure the conclusion weighs which punishment is better rather than only explaining why one is wrong.