'Compassion is more important than keeping marriage vows.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people agree with this statement. Jesus showed great compassion to people whose relationships had failed, such as the woman caught in adultery, whom he refused to condemn (John 8:11), and he taught that loving your neighbour is one of the greatest commandments (Matthew 22:39). Many Christians argue that if a marriage involves abuse, or has completely broken down, forcing a couple to stay together because of their vows would cause great harm to them and to their children. This is why most Protestant churches accept divorce and the Church of England allows divorced people to remarry in church at the discretion of the priest. Situation ethics, a Christian approach, says that in each situation we should do the most loving thing. Buddhists would also stress karuna (compassion) and reducing suffering, and Humanists would argue that people's wellbeing matters more than a promise that has become harmful.
On the other hand, many believers argue that the sanctity of marriage vows must come first. The couple promise before God to stay together 'for better for worse... till death us do part', and Jesus taught 'What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder' (Matthew 19:6). The Catholic Church teaches that a sacramental marriage cannot be dissolved (CCC 1640), and Sikhs see husband and wife as 'one light in two bodies' (Guru Granth Sahib 788). These believers point out that keeping a promise through hard times is itself a form of love, and if vows could be broken whenever life is difficult, they would mean nothing. They also argue that compassion can be shown without breaking vows, for example through counselling, forgiveness or, in the Catholic Church, separation in serious cases (CCC 2383).
In conclusion, I think the answer depends on the situation. In cases of abuse or danger, compassion must come first, and even religions that oppose divorce allow a person to leave such a marriage, for example by separating. However, in ordinary difficulties, keeping marriage vows is one of the most important ways of showing compassion, because it gives security to the partner and to any children. So I partly agree: compassion matters most, but true compassion usually means keeping one's vows wherever that is possible.
Explanation
This statement tests the two ethical arguments named in the specification, so top answers explain both the sanctity of vows and compassion and weigh them against each other with religious teaching applied. Distinguish between abuse and ordinary difficulties, as this leads to a more developed judgement. A conclusion that simply says 'it depends' without explaining on what will not reach the top level.