'Only God should decide when a person dies.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many religious believers would agree with this statement. Christians believe life is a gift from God and that he decides its length: 'the LORD gave, and the LORD hath taken away' (Job 1:21), and Ecclesiastes 3:2 says there is 'a time to be born, and a time to die'. The Catholic Church teaches that people are 'stewards, not owners' of the life God has entrusted to them (CCC 2280), so it is wrong to end it through euthanasia or suicide. Muslims believe in al-Qadr, that Allah has decreed everything, and the Qur'an says that no soul can die except by Allah's leave, at a term appointed (Qur'an 3:145). Sikhs believe in accepting hukam, God's will, and many Jews believe God alone is the master of life and death. For these believers, humans cannot know God's plan, so deliberately choosing the time of death is taking God's place.
However, others disagree. Doctors already make decisions that affect when people die: they switch off life-support machines, decide not to give treatment that would only prolong dying, and use medicine to keep people alive far longer than would happen naturally. Even the Catholic Church accepts that refusing 'over-zealous' or extremely burdensome treatment can be right (CCC 2278), which shows that humans do share in decisions about death. Some Christians argue that God gave humans free will and reason, so a terminally ill person may rightly choose to end their suffering, and that compassion, following Jesus' teaching to love your neighbour, should come first. Buddhists do not believe in a creator God, so for them the question is about intention and compassion rather than God's will. Humanists and atheists do not believe God exists, so they argue that people should make decisions about their own lives, guided by reason, compassion and careful safeguards.
In conclusion, I partly agree. For religious believers the statement is a strong reminder that life is sacred and should not be ended lightly. However, the word 'only' does not reflect reality, because modern medicine means humans are constantly involved in decisions about when people die, and religious traditions themselves accept some of these decisions. I think humans must sometimes make these decisions, but always with great respect for the value of life.
Explanation
The word 'only' is the key: strong answers recognise that even religious traditions accept some human decisions, such as stopping burdensome treatment, while still holding that life should not be deliberately ended. Apply teachings such as Job 1:21, Qur'an 3:145 or CCC 2278 directly to the statement. Include a non-theistic view, such as Buddhist or Humanist thinking, to show reasoned consideration of different points of view.