'Nuclear weapons make the world a safer place.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people, including some religious believers, agree. Since 1945 no nuclear weapon has been used in war, and the major powers have not fought each other directly, even during the Cold War. Supporters of deterrence argue that this is because every nuclear power knows that an attack would lead to its own destruction. The UK keeps at least one Trident submarine on patrol at all times, and Parliament voted in 2016 to replace the submarines. In 1982 Pope John Paul II said that deterrence could still be judged morally acceptable as a step towards disarmament, and in 1983 the Church of England's General Synod rejected the idea that Britain should give up its nuclear weapons on its own. Some Muslims point to the Qur'an's command to make ready strength 'that thereby ye may dismay the enemy' (Qur'an 8:60).
However, many religious believers argue that nuclear weapons make the world more dangerous. There have been near disasters, such as the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962 and a false alarm in 1983, when a Soviet officer, Stanislav Petrov, decided that a warning of an American attack was a computer error. The more countries have these weapons, the greater the risk that one will be used by an unstable leader or stolen by terrorists. Pope Francis said in Hiroshima in 2019 that even possessing nuclear weapons is immoral, and the Catechism warns that the arms race does not ensure peace and diverts resources from those in need (CCC 2315). Buddhists in Soka Gakkai International campaign for abolition because of their belief in the dignity of all life.
Non-religious views differ: some accept deterrence on practical grounds, while the philosopher Bertrand Russell, who was not religious, was the first president of CND and warned with Albert Einstein in 1955 of the danger nuclear war posed to humanity.
In conclusion, I disagree. Deterrence may have helped to prevent a major war so far, but it depends on every leader always acting rationally and on no accident ever happening. A safety that depends on threatening to kill millions of innocent people is fragile, so working for multilateral disarmament is a safer path.
Explanation
High-level answers evaluate deterrence fairly, using evidence such as the absence of nuclear war since 1945 and the near disasters of 1962 and 1983, and apply religious teaching from more than one tradition. Showing that Christian views have changed, from John Paul II in 1982 to Pope Francis in 2019, is a sign of detailed knowledge. The conclusion should judge whether the world is 'safer', not just whether nuclear weapons are moral.