'Religious communities should treat those in same sex relationships in exactly the same way as everyone else.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some religious believers strongly agree that those in same sex relationships should be treated in exactly the same way as everyone else. They argue that every person is made in the image of God (Genesis 1:27) and that Jesus' command to love your neighbour leaves no room for second-class members. Jesus welcomed people whom others rejected, and he taught 'judge not' (Matthew 7:1). For this reason the Methodist Church voted in 2021 to allow same-sex weddings in its chapels, and Reform and Liberal Judaism also conduct same-sex weddings. These believers point out that treating people differently has caused great hurt and has driven many LGBT people away from faith. Humanists would agree, arguing that a loving relationship between consenting adults harms no one.
On the other hand, many believers argue that it is possible to respect people without approving of every relationship. The Catholic Church teaches that people with same-sex attraction must be treated with 'respect, compassion, and sensitivity' (Catechism 2358) and that unjust discrimination is wrong, but it also teaches that sexual relationships belong only in marriage between a man and a woman. The Church of England now allows prayers of blessing for same-sex couples but does not marry them. Most Muslim scholars and Orthodox Jews, applying Leviticus 18:22 and the story of Lut, hold similar views, and many Sikhs believe the Anand Karaj is for a man and a woman. These believers say religions must follow what they believe God has revealed, even when this is unpopular, and UK law protects their freedom not to conduct same-sex marriages.
In conclusion, I think religious communities should treat those in same sex relationships with exactly the same welcome, dignity and care as everyone else, and all religions agree that hatred and bullying are wrong. However, I do not think the statement can be fully true for every religion while their teachings about marriage differ so deeply. Forcing a community to act against its sincere beliefs would itself be unjust, so the best solution is respect for individuals combined with freedom for religious groups to reach their own decisions, which is what is gradually happening as some Churches change and others do not.
Explanation
Top-level answers recognise the range of views, including differences within Christianity (Methodist, Church of England, Catholic) and within Judaism, and apply teachings such as Catechism 2358 or Leviticus 18:22 accurately. The key evaluative point is whether respecting people requires treating every relationship identically, so engage with that rather than simply listing views. Write respectfully and reach a conclusion justified by your reasoning.