'Positive discrimination is the best way to achieve racial equality.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people agree that positive discrimination is the best way to achieve racial equality. They argue that treating everyone in exactly the same way does not produce equality when some groups start with disadvantages caused by racism, past and present. Positive discrimination, such as quotas, could quickly increase the number of people from minority ethnic groups in important jobs, giving young people role models and breaking down stereotypes. Some Christians support this from the idea of justice: Jesus said he came 'to set at liberty them that are bruised' (Luke 4:18), and Catholic social teaching speaks of a preferential option for those who are disadvantaged. In India, many Hindus and Buddhists support the reservation of places for Dalits as justice for centuries of caste discrimination. A utilitarian might also support it if it produced the greatest good overall.
However, many others argue that positive discrimination is not the best way, because it is itself a form of discrimination. Peter taught that 'God is no respecter of persons' (Acts 10:34), and the Prophet Muhammad taught in his Farewell Sermon that no race is better than another except by good conduct, so many Christians and Muslims believe people should be judged on character and ability, not race. It is also generally against the law in the UK, where only positive action, such as encouraging applications and offering training, is allowed. Positive discrimination can cause resentment and make people think those appointed are only 'token' choices, which might even increase prejudice. Martin Luther King dreamed of a nation where people were judged by 'the content of their character', not their skin colour.
In conclusion, I disagree that positive discrimination is the best way. The aim of racial equality is right, and I accept that simply treating everyone identically is not enough. But positive action, education and strong laws against discrimination can tackle disadvantage without creating new unfairness. Religious teaching that God values every individual equally suggests that the best way is to remove the barriers people face and to change prejudiced attitudes, rather than to favour one group over another.
Explanation
Top-level answers apply the ideals of equality and justice to positive discrimination, using religious teaching such as Acts 10:34 or Luke 4:18 on each side. Because the statement says 'best way', compare positive discrimination with other methods, such as positive action or education. Be accurate about UK law, which allows positive action but generally not positive discrimination.