'The Design argument is more convincing than the First Cause argument.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many religious believers would agree that the Design argument is more convincing. It is based on evidence that everyone can see, such as the complexity of the human eye, the structure of DNA and the beauty of the natural world. Paley's analogy of a watch, whose parts work together for a purpose and so must have a maker, is easy to understand. Modern versions such as the anthropic principle point out that the universe is finely tuned for life, which seems very unlikely to be chance. The Design argument also tells us more about God than the First Cause argument does: a designer must be intelligent and purposeful, whereas a first cause might be any kind of cause. It fits with sacred writings too: Psalm 19:1 says 'The heavens declare the glory of God', and the Qur'an says no fault can be seen in Allah's creation (67:3).
On the other hand, many people think the Design argument has been seriously weakened by science. Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection explains how living things come to look designed through small changes over millions of years, without any designer. Atheists such as Richard Dawkins call natural selection a 'blind watchmaker'. Hume also pointed out that the universe is not much like a machine, that there could be many designers, and that evil and suffering suggest a poor design. By contrast, the First Cause argument is based on a simple principle that everyone accepts, that everything that happens has a cause, and modern science seems to support it, because the Big Bang suggests the universe had a beginning. It also answers the deepest question of all: why does anything exist? Some Christians, following Karl Barth, and many Sikhs would say that neither argument really matters, because God is known through revelation and grace, while Humanists reject both as unproven leaps to the supernatural.
In conclusion, I think the First Cause argument is slightly more convincing. The Design argument is more appealing, but evolution gives a natural explanation for the very evidence it relies on, whereas science has not explained why the universe exists at all. However, neither argument proves God on its own, and they are probably strongest when used together, as Aquinas did in his Five Ways.
Explanation
This statement asks for a comparison, so top answers weigh the two arguments against each other rather than describing each one separately. Use strengths and weaknesses of both (Paley, the anthropic principle, Darwin and Hume for design; the Big Bang and 'what caused God?' for the First Cause) and include a religious view on whether arguments matter at all. Make the conclusion follow from the reasons you have weighed.