'Religious creation stories should not be taken literally.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many religious believers agree with this statement. The Catholic Church, the Church of England and many Jews read Genesis as a sacred story that teaches spiritual truths rather than as a scientific record. They point out that a literal reading conflicts with strong evidence: the universe is about 13.8 billion years old and the earth about 4.5 billion years old, so six 24-hour days a few thousand years ago cannot be correct. Genesis 1 and Genesis 2 also give different orders of creation - in chapter 1 humans are made after the animals, but in chapter 2 the man is formed before them - which suggests the writers were not giving a step-by-step history. The Hebrew word for 'day' can mean a long period, and 2 Peter 3:8 says that with the Lord one day is 'as a thousand years'. Read in this way, Genesis still teaches that God is the creator, that creation is 'very good' and that humans are made in God's image.
On the other hand, some Christians, often called Young Earth creationists, and some Orthodox Jews believe the creation stories should be taken literally. They believe scripture is the inspired and inerrant word of God, so it cannot be mistaken. They argue that if Genesis is treated as myth, people may start treating other parts of the Bible, such as the resurrection of Jesus, in the same way. They also note that Jesus referred to God making humans 'male and female' (Matthew 19:4), which they take as support for a historical creation. Many Muslims believe the Qur'an is the exact word of Allah, so they accept its account of Allah creating Adam from clay as true, although many also understand its 'six days' as six long periods, which fits science.
Humanists and atheists would agree that the stories should not be taken literally, but many would go further and say they are human myths from pre-scientific times, valuable as literature but not as truth about the world.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement. A literal reading conflicts with powerful scientific evidence and with details in the texts themselves, while a non-literal reading keeps the stories' most important religious messages. Reading them as symbolic does not make them less true for believers; it means their truth is about meaning and purpose rather than scientific detail.
Explanation
The best answers explain why some believers insist on a literal reading (the authority of scripture) as well as why others do not, and they use evidence from the texts as well as from science. Show differences within religions, such as Young Earth creationists compared with the Catholic Church. Make sure the conclusion weighs the arguments rather than simply repeating one side.