'Religious teachings about same-sex relationships are out of date.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many people would agree with this statement. Attitudes in Britain have changed greatly: same-sex marriage has been legal in England, Wales and Scotland since 2014 and in Northern Ireland since 2020. Some Christians argue that the few Bible passages used against same-sex relationships, such as Leviticus 18:22 and Romans 1:26-27, were written in cultures that knew nothing of loving, faithful same-sex partnerships, so they should not be applied today. They point instead to Jesus' teaching to love your neighbour and to 1 John 4:16, 'God is love', arguing that a committed same-sex relationship can reflect God's love. This is why Quakers, the Methodist Church and the United Reformed Church now conduct same-sex marriages, as do Reform and Liberal Jews. Humanists would add that sexual orientation is a natural part of human diversity, and that morality should be based on consent and avoiding harm, not on ancient texts.
However, many religious believers argue that their teachings cannot be 'out of date', because God's will does not change with public opinion. The Catholic Church teaches that sex is meant for a husband and wife and should be open to new life, so same-sex sexual acts cannot be right (CCC 2357), while insisting that gay people must be treated 'with respect, compassion, and sensitivity' (CCC 2358). Most Muslims believe the Qur'an's account of the people of Lut (7:80-81) shows that same-sex acts are forbidden, and since the Qur'an is Allah's final revelation it cannot become outdated. Orthodox Jews follow Leviticus 18:22 as part of the Torah's eternal commandments, and in 2005 the Akal Takht stated that same-sex marriage is against Sikh teaching. For these believers, a teaching being unpopular does not make it wrong.
Some religious traditions are changing from within. The Church of England still teaches that marriage is between a man and a woman, but since 2023 it has allowed prayers of blessing for same-sex couples within its services.
In conclusion, whether these teachings are 'out of date' depends on what religious teaching is for. If it should reflect a growing understanding of human nature and the central importance of love, then many traditional teachings do seem out of date. But for believers who see scripture as God's unchanging word, the age of a teaching is no reason to reject it. Overall, I partly agree: the strong movement towards acceptance within many religious groups in Britain shows that many believers themselves now regard the traditional teachings as out of date.
Explanation
Top-level answers explain why some believers reinterpret scripture while others see it as unchanging, and apply specific teachings such as CCC 2357-2358, 1 John 4:16 or Leviticus 18:22. Show the differences within religions (for example between the Catholic Church and Quakers, or Orthodox and Reform Jews) and represent every view respectfully. A justified conclusion should weigh whether 'old' means 'wrong', rather than just summarising both sides.