'It should be up to each couple, not religious leaders, to decide whether to use contraception.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you:
- should give reasoned arguments in support of this statement
- should give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- should refer to religious arguments
- may refer to non-religious arguments
- should reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many people would agree with this statement. A married couple understand their own circumstances best: their health, their finances and how many children they can care for. Many Anglican and other Protestant Christians believe that contraception is a matter for a couple's conscience; the Lambeth Conference of 1958 taught that decisions about the number and spacing of children have been laid by God on the consciences of parents. Reform and Liberal Jews also leave the choice to the couple, and Sikh scripture contains no teaching on contraception, so many Sikhs see it as a decision for husband and wife. Humanists would strongly agree, arguing that decisions about having children are personal and that everyone should have access to safe, reliable contraception, as they do through the NHS.
However, other believers argue that couples should be guided by religious leaders. The Catholic Church teaches that its Magisterium (teaching authority) interprets God's will, and Humanae Vitae (1968) clearly teaches that artificial contraception is wrong because every act of sex must remain open to life. Catholics believe conscience must be formed by Church teaching rather than personal preference, so the Church's guidance protects couples from making selfish choices. Many Orthodox Jews ask a rabbi before using contraception, because Jewish law (halakhah) permits it only in certain situations, such as risk to the mother's health. Many Muslims seek the advice of scholars to make sure a method is permitted and does not cause an early abortion. For these believers, religious leaders are not taking away the couple's freedom but helping them to obey God.
It is worth noting that even the Catholic Church agrees that couples themselves should decide, for just reasons and without selfishness, whether to space the births of their children (CCC 2368). The disagreement is mainly about which methods may be used.
In conclusion, I largely agree with the statement. Only the couple can weigh up their own health, relationship and circumstances, and a decision forced on them would not be a free, responsible choice. However, religious believers will want their consciences to be shaped by their faith, so the wisest approach is for the couple to make the final decision while listening seriously to the teaching of their religion.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh conscience against religious authority, using specific evidence such as the Lambeth Conference of 1958, Humanae Vitae or the role of rabbis and scholars. Recognise that the question is about who decides, not just whether contraception is right. A justified conclusion explains why one argument is stronger, for example by showing how conscience and religious teaching can work together.