Item A
Soar Valley Appliances Ltd
Soar Valley Appliances Ltd makes toasters and kettles at a factory in Loughborough and sells them to department stores and online retailers. It employs 85 staff, including 70 production workers who are paid a bonus based on the number of toasters they assemble each day.
The business uses quality control. Three inspectors test a sample of finished toasters at the end of the production line. A faulty toaster found at this stage has to be taken apart and rebuilt, which takes about 20 minutes. Last year a fault in one batch was missed, and 4 800 toasters had to be recalled because their thermostats could overheat. The recall cost £96 000 for collecting, refunding and replacing toasters, and a large department store chain has stopped stocking Soar Valley's toasters.
The managing director, Harjit, is considering replacing quality control with total quality management (TQM). Every production worker would be trained to check their own work at each stage of assembly and would be able to stop the line if they found a problem. The training would cost £45 000, and the factory would lose two days of production while it took place. The three inspectors would become quality trainers. Some production workers have said they are worried that checking their own work will slow them down and reduce their bonuses.
Table 1 shows the factory's toaster production last year.
Harjit wants to reduce the number of faulty toasters.
Recommend whether Soar Valley Appliances Ltd should replace quality control with total quality management (TQM). Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
Soar Valley's quality control is not working well. Faults found by inspectors rose from 540 in January-March (1.5% of toasters made) to 966 in October-December (2.3%), and returns from customers rose from 288 to 630. Because the inspectors test only a sample at the end of the line, some faults are missed: one missed fault led to a recall of 4 800 toasters that cost £96 000 and lost the business a large department store customer.
TQM would tackle these problems at their source. If every worker checks their own work at each stage and can stop the line, a fault is put right immediately instead of being found at the end, when the toaster has to be taken apart and rebuilt in about 20 minutes. In October-December alone, rebuilding 966 toasters took about 322 hours of work, so preventing faults would save labour and materials and lower the cost of each toaster. Fewer faulty toasters would also mean fewer returns and less risk of another recall, which would protect Soar Valley's reputation and could help win back the department store chain. The £45 000 training cost is less than half the cost of the last recall.
However, TQM only works if the workers are committed to it. At the moment they are paid a bonus for each toaster they assemble, so they are rewarded for speed, not quality. Some already fear that checking their work will cut their bonuses, so they may rush their checks and quality may not improve. The business would also lose two days of production during the training.
I recommend that Soar Valley should introduce TQM, because its rising fault rate and costly recall show that checking a sample at the end of the line is not enough. However, this depends on Harjit changing the bonus so that it rewards toasters made without faults; otherwise workers will have no reason to take responsibility for quality. Keeping a final safety test on a sample of toasters for the first few months would also reduce the risk while TQM is introduced.
Explanation
Level 3 answers use the data to show the problem is growing (faults found rose from 1.5% to 2.3% of output and returns more than doubled), compare the £45 000 cost of TQM with the £96 000 recall, and weigh this against the bonus scheme, which rewards speed rather than quality. The recommendation should be justified and can include conditions, such as changing the bonus. Confusing TQM with more inspection, or making generic points about TQM, will not reach the top level.