Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/21

Legislation

Practise 17 exam-style questions on Legislation for AQA GCSE Business (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 17 questions
  • 1–12 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
17 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

A business sells kitchen knives labelled 'stainless steel'. Some of the knives rust after the first wash because they are made from a cheaper steel.

Which law has the business most likely broken?

Choose your answer.

  • Consumer law
  • The Equality Act 2010
  • The Health and Safety at Work Act 1974
  • National minimum wage law

Model answer

Consumer law

Explanation

Consumer law requires goods to be as described, of satisfactory quality and fit for purpose (for example under the Consumer Rights Act 2015), and businesses must not give false or misleading descriptions of their products. Knives labelled 'stainless steel' that rust are not as described, so customers are entitled to a refund, repair or replacement, and the business could face action by Trading Standards. The Health and Safety at Work Act protects employees at work, not customers who buy faulty goods.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Consumer law

    If more than one option is given, 0 marks.

Question 2

2 marks

Explain one way the Equality Act 2010 affects how a business treats its existing employees.

Model answer

The Equality Act 2010 means men and women doing equal work must receive equal pay. The business may therefore need to review its pay rates and raise the pay of some employees, which increases its wage costs.

Explanation

The Equality Act protects employees from discrimination because of protected characteristics, in pay, training, promotion, redundancy and working conditions, and requires reasonable adjustments for disabled staff. A full answer names one requirement and explains its effect on the business, such as costs, fairer decisions or the risk of a tribunal. 'Everyone must be treated equally' is too vague without an example of what the Act covers.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Identifies a requirement: equal pay for men and women doing equal work / no discrimination in promotion, training or redundancy because of a protected characteristic / reasonable adjustments for disabled employees / prevent harassment or bullying linked to a protected characteristic

    Protected characteristics are age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex, and sexual orientation. The answer must show what the Act requires, eg an example of a characteristic or situation it protects.

  2. 1 mark

    Explains the effect on the business: eg it may have to review pay rates, which could raise wage costs / decisions on promotion or training must be based on skills and performance / it must spend money adapting equipment or the workplace / it must train managers / it could face an employment tribunal and compensation if it discriminates

    Examples of developed answers: Men and women doing equal work must get equal pay (1) so the business may have to raise some wages, increasing its costs (1). It must make reasonable adjustments for disabled employees (1) such as adapting equipment, which costs money but keeps skilled staff (1). It cannot choose who to make redundant because of age (1) so it must use fair criteria such as skills, or risk a tribunal claim (1). Do not accept 'treat everyone the same' without an example of what the Act protects.

Question 3

4 marks

Item A
Northfield Distribution Ltd

Northfield Distribution Ltd stores and delivers goods for online retailers. It is opening a new warehouse near Doncaster and needs to recruit 60 warehouse operatives and 4 shift supervisors before the warehouse opens in three months. Operatives pick and pack orders, which involves lifting boxes of up to 15 kg, and supervisors organise each shift from an office on the warehouse floor.

A manager's first draft of the job advert asked for 'young, strong men aged 18 to 30'. The human resources manager, Abena, stopped the advert from being published. She rewrote it to describe the tasks of the job and the skills needed, and added that all applicants would take a practical lifting and picking test.

One of the strongest applicants for a supervisor role uses a wheelchair. To make the role suitable, Northfield would need to fit a ramp to the supervisors' office and buy an adjustable desk, costing about £2 800 in total.

Abena also wants all 12 managers who will interview applicants to attend a one-day course on equality law, costing £3 600. She has reminded the directors that last year a competitor had to pay £45 000 after an employment tribunal found that it had discriminated against an older job applicant, and that the case was reported in the local news.

The Doncaster area has a large working-age population of all ages and from many different backgrounds, and Northfield needs to fill all 64 jobs quickly.

Explain one way the Equality Act 2010 affects how Northfield Distribution Ltd recruits staff for its new warehouse.

You should use the information in Item A in your answer.

Model answer

The Equality Act 2010 means Northfield must not discriminate against applicants because of protected characteristics such as age, sex or disability. The first draft of the advert asking for 'young, strong men aged 18 to 30' would have broken the law, because it excluded women and older people. Instead, Abena has rewritten it to describe the tasks and skills needed, with a practical lifting and picking test, so that every applicant is judged on whether they can do the job. Northfield must also make reasonable adjustments for disabled applicants, so it would need to spend about £2 800 on a ramp and an adjustable desk to appoint the wheelchair user as a supervisor.

Explanation

Level 2 needs one effect of the Act on recruitment, such as fair job adverts, selection based on skills, reasonable adjustments or training interviewers, explained with Northfield's evidence. The draft advert is the clearest example to use, because it shows how the Act changes the way the business describes and selects for the job. A general description of the Equality Act, not linked to Northfield, stays in Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO1 = 2, AO2 = 2.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Sound understanding and application of the topics. Applies knowledge and understanding to the context sufficiently. A sound understanding of one or more business concepts and issues.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Basic understanding and application of the topics. Applies basic knowledge and understanding to the context. A basic understanding of one or more business concepts.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Knowledge and application: the Act makes it unlawful to discriminate against applicants because of protected characteristics such as age, sex, race or disability; the draft advert for 'young, strong men aged 18 to 30' would have discriminated by age and sex, so Abena rewrote it to describe the tasks and skills and added a practical lifting and picking test for all applicants, so selection is based on ability to do the job; Northfield must make reasonable adjustments for disabled applicants, so it would spend about £2 800 on a ramp and an adjustable desk to appoint the wheelchair user as a supervisor; managers who interview must avoid discriminatory questions, so Northfield is spending £3 600 training 12 managers; failing to follow the Act risks an employment tribunal, as when a competitor paid £45 000. Level 2 needs a sound explanation of one effect on Northfield's recruitment, applied using the case. An answer not applied to Northfield cannot go above Level 1.

Question 4

9 marks

Item A
Sherwell Garden Products Ltd

Sherwell Garden Products Ltd fills, packs and labels bags of compost, bark chippings and barbecue charcoal for three UK supermarket chains at a large factory near Newark in Nottinghamshire. It employs 160 people, including 110 packers who work on the packing lines. All of the packers are paid the National Living Wage or the national minimum wage for their age.

The government has announced a rise in the National Living Wage from next April. Sherwell estimates that this will increase the total pay of its packers by 4%. This year the packers' total pay is £2 600 000. Last year Sherwell made a profit of £520 000. Its supermarket customers have said they will not accept higher prices.

Sherwell also has a staffing problem. About 40% of its packers leave each year, many of them to a new distribution warehouse nearby that pays more. Recruiting and training each new packer costs about £900, and new packers make more mistakes: last year 3% of pallets were rejected by the supermarkets for wrongly packed or wrongly labelled products, mostly from lines with several new starters.

The operations director, Grace, wants to pay all packers 5% more than the legal minimum for their age. She believes this would halve staff turnover, improve quality and make it easier to recruit extra staff for the busy summer season. The finance director points out that this would add about £135 000 a year to the wage bill, on top of the rise in the National Living Wage.

Grace wants to pay all packers 5% more than the legal minimum for their age.

Recommend whether Sherwell Garden Products Ltd should pay its packers 5% more than the legal minimum. Give reasons for your recommendation.

Model answer

Sherwell should pay its packers 5% more than the legal minimum, because its staffing problems are costing it more than they first appear to.

At the moment about 40% of the 110 packers leave each year, which is around 44 people. Recruiting and training each one costs about £900, so turnover costs roughly £40 000 a year. If Grace is right and turnover halves, this would save about £20 000 a year. More importantly, a more experienced workforce should make fewer mistakes. Last year 3% of pallets were rejected by the supermarkets, mostly from lines with new starters. Rejected pallets waste stock and labour, and if mistakes continue Sherwell risks losing one of only three supermarket customers, which would cost far more than the pay rise. Higher pay would also help Sherwell compete with the nearby warehouse for staff and recruit the extra workers it needs for the busy summer season.

However, the cost is very high. The rise in the National Living Wage will already add about £104 000 to the packers' pay, which is 20% of last year's profit of £520 000. Paying 5% above the legal minimum would add another £135 000, so together the two increases would cut profit by about £239 000, nearly half. The supermarkets will not accept higher prices, so Sherwell cannot pass these costs on. The saving in recruitment and training, about £20 000, is much smaller than £135 000, so the plan only pays for itself if quality and productivity improve a lot.

On balance, Sherwell should introduce the higher pay, but it could reduce the risk by linking it to staying with the business, for example paying the extra 5% once a packer has completed six months. This targets the money at reducing turnover. The decision depends on how much the rejected pallets are really costing Sherwell, and on whether the supermarkets value better quality enough to keep giving it contracts.

Explanation

Level 3 needs a clear recommendation that weighs the voluntary extra cost (£135 000 on top of the legal rise) against the cost of high staff turnover, recruitment and rejected pallets, using the case figures. Strong answers recognise that the law only sets a minimum, so paying more is a choice, and judge whether the savings in turnover and quality are big enough. A generic answer about pay and motivation, without Sherwell's evidence, cannot go above Level 2.

Mark scheme
  1. 9 marks

    Levels of response (9 marks). AO2 = 3, AO3 = 6.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Detailed analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. Sustained line of reasoning, which is coherent, relevant, substantiated with a focused conclusion that is fully justified. Business areas are fully analysed. Applies knowledge and understanding to the context sufficiently.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Sound analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. A line of reasoning, with a conclusion that has some justification. Business areas are partially analysed. Applies some knowledge and understanding to the context.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. Basic line of reasoning with a conclusion. Basic analysis of business areas. Basic knowledge and understanding is applied to the context.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Application: 110 packers, all on the National Living Wage or the minimum wage for their age; the coming rise adds 4% to £2 600 000 (about £104 000, a fifth of last year's £520 000 profit); supermarkets will not accept higher prices; about 40% of packers leave each year (about 44 people), many to a nearby warehouse that pays more; about £900 to recruit and train each new packer (about £40 000 a year); 3% of pallets rejected, mostly from lines with new starters; extra staff needed for summer; Grace's plan adds about £135 000 a year and she expects turnover to halve. Analysis (for): higher pay than the legal minimum helps Sherwell compete with the warehouse for staff, so fewer packers leave and recruitment for the summer is easier; halving turnover saves about £20 000 a year in recruitment and training; a more experienced workforce makes fewer packing and labelling errors, so fewer pallets are rejected, less stock and labour are wasted and the supermarket contracts are protected; better motivated staff may be more productive. Analysis (against): the law only requires the minimum, so the extra £135 000 is a voluntary cost on top of the £104 000 legal rise, together cutting profit by nearly half; the supermarkets will not pay more, so the cost cannot be passed on; the recruitment saving (about £20 000) is far smaller than the cost, so the plan depends on large quality and productivity gains; turnover may not halve if the warehouse raises its pay too. Evaluation - what does it depend on?: how much rejected pallets really cost and how close Sherwell is to losing a supermarket contract; whether a smaller rise, a rise only for experienced packers, or other methods (better training, a bonus for staying) would work as well; whether profit can absorb the cost. Accept any well-argued recommendation. Level 3 needs a recommendation fully justified using the case. A generic answer that does not use the case cannot go above Level 2, however well developed.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.