Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/21

Ethical and environmental considerations

Practise 17 exam-style questions on Ethical and environmental considerations for AQA GCSE Business (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 17 questions
  • 1–12 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
17 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

Which one of the following is most likely to be a drawback to a business of behaving more ethically?

Choose your answer.

  • Higher costs, which may reduce profit
  • A better reputation with customers
  • Lower labour turnover
  • Fewer fines for breaking the law

Model answer

Higher costs, which may reduce profit

Explanation

Behaving ethically, for example paying suppliers and staff more or buying from inspected factories, usually costs more, so there is often a trade-off between ethics and profit. A better reputation, lower labour turnover and fewer fines are all benefits of ethical behaviour. Strong answers recognise that these benefits may, over time, outweigh the extra costs.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Higher costs, which may reduce profit

    Accept 'higher costs'. If more than one option is given, 0 marks.

Question 2

2 marks

Explain one benefit to a business of treating its employees ethically.

Model answer

If a business treats its employees ethically, for example by paying them fairly and keeping them safe, they are less likely to leave. This means the business spends less money and time recruiting and training replacements, and it keeps experienced staff who make fewer mistakes.

Explanation

One mark is for the benefit and one for explaining how it helps the business, such as lower recruitment costs or higher productivity. Describing what ethical treatment is, without a benefit to the business, does not answer the question.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Identifying a benefit: more motivated employees / higher productivity / lower labour turnover or absence / easier to recruit staff / better reputation with customers or the public / fewer legal claims or fines / better quality or customer service

    Max 1. Accept a benefit that follows from a named ethical action, e.g. 'paying fair wages', 'safe working conditions', 'guaranteed hours'.

  2. 1 mark

    Explaining the benefit / its consequence for the business

    Max 1. Examples of developed answers: Employees who are paid fairly feel valued and are more motivated (1), so they work harder and productivity rises (1). Staff are less likely to leave (1), so the business spends less on recruiting and training replacements (1). The business gains a reputation as a good employer (1), so it can attract skilled applicants more easily (1). A description of ethical behaviour on its own, with no benefit to the business, scores 0.

Question 3

4 marks

Item C
Tansley & Webb Building Supplies Ltd

Tansley & Webb Building Supplies Ltd sells bricks, timber, cement and other materials to builders. Its depot is on the edge of a Derbyshire village, beside the main road through the village and 200 metres from a primary school. It employs 35 staff, including 12 lorry drivers, and has 10 diesel lorries.

The depot opens at 6 am, when lorries are loaded using forklift trucks and leave to make deliveries before builders start work. Large deliveries from suppliers arrive during the day, and lorries often queue on the main road waiting to enter the depot, particularly at the start and end of the school day. Residents have complained to the local council about the noise of reversing alarms and forklift trucks early in the morning, and about traffic jams and fumes near the school. A local newspaper has reported the complaints, and the council has said it will consider limiting the depot's opening hours.

Tansley & Webb's operations manager, Aisha, is considering replacing the diesel lorries with electric lorries over the next three years. Electric lorries cost about twice as much to buy, but they are much quieter, produce no exhaust fumes and cost less to run. Each electric lorry can travel about 150 miles before it needs recharging, and most of Tansley & Webb's deliveries are within 30 miles of the depot. Charging points would cost £60 000 to install, and the drivers would need training.

Explain one way that Tansley & Webb Building Supplies Ltd's operations are affecting the local environment.

You should use the information in Item C in your answer.

Model answer

Tansley & Webb's operations are adding to traffic congestion in the village. Its depot is beside the main road, and lorries delivering to the depot often queue on the road waiting to get in, particularly at the start and end of the school day, when parents are taking children to the primary school 200 metres away. These queues block the main road and slow down other traffic, and the waiting diesel lorries add fumes near the school. As a result residents have complained to the council, which is considering limiting the depot's opening hours.

Explanation

Level 2 needs one environmental effect, such as congestion, noise or air pollution, explained using Tansley & Webb's own details: the main road, the queues at school times, the 6 am start or the diesel lorries. Answers that list environmental problems in general, without linking them to Tansley & Webb's operations, stay at Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO1 = 2, AO2 = 2.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Sound understanding and application of the topics. Applies knowledge and understanding to the context sufficiently. A sound understanding of one or more business concepts and issues.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Basic understanding and application of the topics. Applies basic knowledge and understanding to the context. A basic understanding of one or more business concepts.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Knowledge: business activity can affect the environment through traffic congestion, noise pollution and air pollution. Application and explanation (traffic congestion): the depot is beside the main road through the village; lorries delivering to the depot queue on the road waiting to enter, especially at the start and end of the school day, so the road is blocked and journeys for residents and parents are slower. Application and explanation (noise pollution): the depot opens at 6 am, and reversing alarms and forklift trucks loading 10 lorries disturb residents early in the morning. Application and explanation (air pollution): 10 diesel lorries, plus queuing suppliers' lorries, give off exhaust fumes near a primary school 200 metres away, so children breathe in more polluted air. Consequences for Tansley & Webb: complaints to the council, a newspaper story and the risk that the council limits the depot's opening hours. Level 2 (3-4): a sound explanation of one environmental effect, applied to Tansley & Webb (e.g. queuing lorries at school times causing congestion). Level 1 (1-2): a basic explanation of an environmental effect, or case facts listed with little explanation. Cap: an answer not applied to Tansley & Webb Building Supplies Ltd cannot go above Level 1. Only one way needs to be explained; if several are given, credit the best.

Question 4

9 marks

Item A
Marsden & Iqbal Workwear Ltd

Marsden & Iqbal Workwear Ltd makes high-visibility jackets and work trousers in a factory in Huddersfield. It sells mainly to councils and construction companies, which choose their suppliers through tenders: they compare several suppliers' prices and standards before awarding a contract. Marsden & Iqbal employs 110 staff and makes 40 000 jackets a year.

Marsden & Iqbal buys the fabric for its jackets from an overseas supplier, at a cost of £6.50 per jacket. Last month a charity published a report claiming that workers at the supplier's factory work 12-hour shifts, six days a week, and that fire exits are kept locked. Marsden & Iqbal's managers cannot easily check these claims, because the factory is 5 000 miles away and they have never visited it.

An alternative supplier in Portugal is independently inspected to make sure its workers are paid fairly and work safely. Its fabric is of similar quality but costs 20% more. Deliveries from Portugal would take one week instead of five, so Marsden & Iqbal could hold less fabric in stock.

Marsden & Iqbal's prices are already slightly higher than those of its main rival, which imports finished jackets. Two of Marsden & Iqbal's largest customers, both councils, have said that from next year their tenders will award extra points to suppliers that can prove their materials are ethically sourced. Marsden & Iqbal's net profit last year was £180 000.

Recommend whether Marsden & Iqbal Workwear Ltd should change to the fabric supplier in Portugal. Give reasons for your recommendation.

Model answer

Changing to the supplier in Portugal would be the ethical choice. The charity's report claims that workers at the current supplier work 12-hour shifts, six days a week, with locked fire exits, which puts their lives at risk. If Marsden & Iqbal carries on buying from this factory and the claims are true, it is profiting from unsafe and unfair treatment of workers. The Portuguese supplier is independently inspected, so Marsden & Iqbal could prove that its fabric is ethically sourced. This also matters commercially, because two of Marsden & Iqbal's largest customers will give extra points in their tenders from next year to suppliers that can prove ethical sourcing, so switching could help Marsden & Iqbal keep these contracts. Deliveries would also take one week instead of five, so Marsden & Iqbal could hold less fabric in stock, freeing up cash and space.

However, there is a trade-off between ethics and profit. The fabric costs 20% more, so the cost per jacket rises from £6.50 to £7.80, and the total fabric bill rises from £260 000 to £312 000 a year. The extra £52 000 is about 29% of last year's net profit of £180 000. Marsden & Iqbal's prices are already slightly higher than its main rival's, so if it raises prices further it may lose tenders that are decided mainly on price; if it does not, its profit will fall.

I recommend that Marsden & Iqbal should change to the Portuguese supplier. The councils' new tender rules mean that ethical sourcing will soon affect Marsden & Iqbal's sales, and the damage to its reputation if the charity's claims are proved true could cost far more than £52 000 a year. The shorter delivery time also brings savings on stock that partly offset the higher cost. However, this depends on how many points the councils give for ethical sourcing compared with price, and on whether Marsden & Iqbal can pass some of the extra £1.30 per jacket on to customers who value ethical sourcing.

Explanation

A Level 3 answer identifies the trade-off between ethics and profit and uses the case to weigh it: the £52 000 extra cost against £180 000 profit, Marsden & Iqbal's already higher prices, and the councils' new tender points for ethical sourcing. Answers that only say ethical behaviour is 'the right thing to do', without considering the effect on Marsden & Iqbal's costs and sales, rarely get beyond Level 2.

Mark scheme
  1. 9 marks

    Levels of response (9 marks). AO2 = 3, AO3 = 6.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Detailed analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. Sustained line of reasoning, which is coherent, relevant, substantiated with a focused conclusion that is fully justified. Business areas are fully analysed. Applies knowledge and understanding to the context sufficiently.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Sound analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. A line of reasoning, with a conclusion that has some justification. Business areas are partially analysed. Applies some knowledge and understanding to the context.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. Basic line of reasoning with a conclusion. Basic analysis of business areas. Basic knowledge and understanding is applied to the context.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Application: the charity's report claims 12-hour shifts, six days a week and locked fire exits at the current supplier; Marsden & Iqbal cannot easily check, as the factory is 5 000 miles away and managers have never visited; the Portuguese supplier is independently inspected for fair pay and safety; similar quality; fabric costs 20% more (£6.50 to £7.80 a jacket; £260 000 to £312 000 a year for 40 000 jackets, £52 000 extra, about 29% of last year's £180 000 net profit); deliveries in one week instead of five, so less fabric held in stock; Marsden & Iqbal's prices are already slightly higher than its main rival's; two of its largest customers, both councils, will give extra points in tenders for proven ethical sourcing from next year. Analysis for: acting fairly towards the workers who make its materials; proof of ethical sourcing helps win council tenders, protecting sales; avoids damage to reputation if the claims are proved; shorter delivery times mean less stock, less cash and space tied up and a faster response to orders. Analysis against (trade-off between ethics and profit): £52 000 a year extra costs reduce profit unless prices rise; higher prices could lose tenders that are mainly decided on price, as Marsden & Iqbal is already dearer than its rival; Marsden & Iqbal could instead investigate the claims or ask the current supplier to improve. Evaluation (what does it depend on?): how many points the councils give for ethical sourcing compared with price; whether other customers will pay more for ethically sourced jackets; whether the charity's claims are true; how much the shorter delivery time saves in stock. Level 3 (7-9): a recommendation fully justified with a sustained line of reasoning using the case, weighing ethics against profit. Level 2 (4-6): sound analysis with a conclusion that has some justification. Level 1 (1-3): basic points with a simple conclusion. Cap: a generic answer that does not use the case cannot go above Level 2, however well developed. Either recommendation can reach Level 3; an answer with no recommendation cannot reach Level 3.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.