Item A
Pennywell Laundry Services Ltd
Pennywell Laundry Services Ltd is a commercial laundry in Exeter. It washes and irons bed linen, towels and uniforms for 70 hotels, care homes and restaurants in Devon, and employs 85 staff, many of them part-time.
At the start of 2025 the business was losing customers. Staff turnover was high, so many workers were new and still learning, and 5% of items were sent back by customers because they had not been washed or ironed properly. The directors set four objectives for 2025. Table 1 shows the targets and the results.
To achieve the objectives, the directors raised pay for all production staff, introduced a training programme for new workers and spent £60 000 on two new ironing machines. These changes were the main reason that net profit fell in 2025. The pay rise alone has increased the wage bill by £45 000 a year, and this cost will continue in future years.
No customers left Pennywell during 2025, and by the end of the year it had won six new hotel contracts, which start in 2026. The directors expect net profit to rise to about £140 000 in 2026.
Evaluate whether 2025 was a successful year for Pennywell Laundry Services Ltd. Give reasons for your answer.
Model answer
In many ways 2025 was a successful year for Pennywell, because it met all three of its non-financial objectives. Staff turnover fell from 28% to 15%, beating the target of 18%. This matters because, at the start of the year, many workers were new and still learning, which was one reason so many items were sent back. With more experienced staff and the new training programme, items sent back for rewashing fell from 5% to 1.8%, better than the 2% target. As a result, customer satisfaction rose from 79% to 91%, well above the 85% target. These results show that the business has fixed the problem that was making it lose customers: no customers left during 2025, and it has won six new hotel contracts starting in 2026.
However, Pennywell missed its profit objective badly. It aimed to increase net profit by 10% to £132 000, but net profit fell from £120 000 to £102 000, a fall of 15%. Higher pay, the training programme and the £60 000 spent on two new ironing machines all increased costs, and the pay rise will keep adding £45 000 a year to the wage bill. If profit kept falling, the business would have less money to reinvest, and the owners might lose confidence in the directors.
Overall, I think 2025 was a successful year. The fall in profit was caused mainly by decisions to invest in staff and machines, which are the reasons the other objectives were met. The machines have now been paid for, lower staff turnover reduces recruitment and training costs, and the six new contracts will bring in extra revenue from 2026, which is why the directors expect profit to rise to about £140 000. Success can be measured in other ways than profit, and Pennywell is in a much stronger position than a year ago. This judgement depends on the new contracts delivering that higher profit despite the permanent rise in wages. If profit does not recover in 2026, the 2025 results would look much less successful.
Explanation
Top-level answers judge success against each objective in Table 1, explain how the results are linked (lower staff turnover led to fewer items sent back, which raised satisfaction and won contracts) and weigh this against the 15% fall in profit and the lasting £45 000 rise in wages. The conclusion must follow from that weighing and say what it depends on. Answers that only list which targets were met, without analysis or a justified judgement, stay in Level 1 or 2.