Item A
Lowther Windows Ltd
Lowther Windows Ltd manufactures made-to-measure windows and doors in a factory in Carlisle, Cumbria, and sells them to builders and home-improvement companies. It employs 60 production workers on a production line. Each worker does one task, such as cutting frames, fitting glass or adding handles, and supervisors check the quality of finished windows at the end of the line.
Production workers are paid an hourly wage. Many say their work is boring, and staff turnover is 28% a year. Last year, 6% of windows failed the final quality check and had to be repaired, often because a fault made early on the line was not noticed until the end. Customers have complained about late deliveries.
The operations director, Callum, is considering a change to team working. Workers would be organised into teams of six, each building complete windows. Each team would plan its own work, rotate tasks, check the quality of its own windows and suggest improvements. Workers would be trained in all tasks, which would take six weeks and reduce output by about 15% while the training takes place. Two of the five supervisors' jobs would no longer be needed, and these supervisors would be offered roles as team coaches.
Some long-serving workers have said they prefer their current jobs and do not want extra responsibility. A rival manufacturer that introduced team working two years ago reports that its faults fell by half.
Recommend whether Lowther Windows Ltd should introduce team working with greater responsibility for its production workers. Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that Lowther introduces team working.
At present each worker does one task on a production line, and many say the work is boring. This low motivation is shown by staff turnover of 28% a year, which means Lowther is constantly recruiting and training new workers. In teams of six, workers would build complete windows, rotate tasks, plan their own work and suggest improvements. This gives them more variety and greater responsibility, so they are likely to feel trusted and more motivated, and fewer of them should leave.
Team working should also improve quality. Last year 6% of windows failed the final check, often because a fault made early on the line was not noticed until the end. If each team checks the quality of its own windows, faults are more likely to be spotted and put right straight away, so less time is spent on repairs and deliveries are less likely to be late. A rival that introduced team working found that its faults fell by half, so a similar result at Lowther would cut its failure rate to about 3%.
However, there are risks. Training all workers would take six weeks and cut output by about 15%, which could make late deliveries worse in the short term and lose customers who are already complaining. Some long-serving workers do not want extra responsibility and might become less motivated or leave, and two supervisors would lose their current jobs.
Overall, the benefits are greater than the risks, because high staff turnover and the 6% failure rate are long-term problems that cost Lowther money every year, while the fall in output lasts only six weeks. However, success depends on how the change is managed, so Lowther should introduce teams gradually, starting with workers who want to take part, so that output and deliveries are protected.