Item A
Penhallow Pasties Ltd
Penhallow Pasties Ltd is a family-owned private limited company in Redruth, Cornwall. It makes handmade pasties using beef, potatoes and swede bought from farms within 30 miles of its bakery. It employs 64 production workers, most of whom live in the town, and the bakery works from Monday to Friday, 6 am to 4 pm.
Two years ago a supermarket chain began selling Penhallow's pasties in 40 of its stores in the South West. The bakery is now working at full capacity. The supermarket has asked for an extra 6 000 pasties each weekend, when its sales of pasties are highest, and has said it may look for another supplier if Penhallow cannot help.
The managing director, Morwenna, is considering opening the bakery on Saturdays and Sundays. Weekend shifts would be paid at time-and-a-half, and workers would choose whether to take them. Table 1 shows the results of a staff survey. If not enough staff volunteer, Penhallow would need to recruit and train new bakers, which takes about six weeks.
The bakery is on a small industrial estate next to a housing estate. Delivery lorries currently arrive and leave only on weekdays. Some residents have already complained to the local council about lorries parking on their street early in the morning.
The farms that supply Penhallow have said they can provide the extra ingredients, but the potato grower wants to be paid within 14 days instead of the current 30 days.
The shareholders, who are all members of Morwenna's family, received no dividend last year because the profit was used to buy a second oven.
Recommend whether Penhallow Pasties Ltd should open the bakery at weekends. Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
Opening at weekends would help Penhallow keep its most important customer. The supermarket sells its pasties in 40 stores and wants an extra 6 000 pasties each weekend, when its sales are highest. The bakery is already at full capacity on weekdays, so weekend production is the only way to meet this demand. If Penhallow refuses, the supermarket may find another supplier, and Penhallow could lose not just the weekend order but possibly the whole contract, which would put jobs at risk. Extra sales would raise revenue and profit, which matters to the family shareholders because they received no dividend last year.
Weekend shifts would also meet the objectives of many employees. Table 1 shows that 37 of the 64 workers are willing to work weekends, and time-and-a-half pay would increase their earnings.
However, there are drawbacks. Time-and-a-half wages raise the labour cost of each weekend pasty, so the profit on each one will be lower than on a weekday. Only 12 workers will work every weekend and 27 will not work weekends at all, so Penhallow may have to recruit and train new bakers, which takes six weeks and adds cost. Residents already complain about lorries parking on their street, and weekend deliveries could lead to more complaints to the council. The potato grower also wants to be paid in 14 days instead of 30, which would put pressure on cash flow.
Overall, I recommend that Penhallow should open at weekends. The risk of losing a customer that sells its pasties in 40 stores is greater than the extra costs, and even at time-and-a-half the extra 6 000 pasties a weekend should add to profit and allow a dividend. However, this depends on enough staff volunteering. Penhallow should start with the 37 volunteers, recruit a few weekend bakers, and agree delivery times with residents, such as lorries waiting on the industrial estate, so that conflict with the local community is kept low.