Item A
The Old Granary Hotel
The Old Granary Hotel is a 24-bedroom hotel in Ludlow, Shropshire, owned by the Whitfield family as a private limited company. Its restaurant is open to the public as well as to hotel guests and earns about 40% of the hotel's revenue. Online reviews often praise the food, and the restaurant was recently listed in a regional good food guide. However, the hotel has started to lose restaurant bookings to two newer restaurants in the town that offer more modern menus.
The head chef, who has worked at the hotel for 15 years, retires in three months, and the owners must decide how to fill the post.
Internal option: promote the sous chef, Owain. He has worked alongside the head chef for six years and knows the menu, the suppliers and the kitchen team well. He is popular with the four other kitchen staff and would accept a salary of £36 000. However, he has never run a kitchen on his own, has no experience of controlling food costs, and has said he would like to keep the menu 'much as it is'. If Owain is promoted, the hotel will need to recruit a new sous chef.
External option: advertise the post nationally on a specialist hospitality jobs website, at a cost of £650. Shortlisted applicants would be invited to an interview and a 'cook-off', in which each must prepare a three-course meal from a set list of ingredients in 90 minutes, to be tasted by the owners. Several chefs with experience in larger restaurants, including creating new menus, have recently applied for similar jobs in the area. An external head chef would probably expect a salary of about £42 000.
Recommend whether The Old Granary Hotel should promote Owain to head chef or recruit a head chef externally. Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
I recommend that the hotel recruits a head chef externally.
The main reason is that the hotel is losing bookings to two newer restaurants in the town that offer more modern menus. Owain has said he would like to keep the menu 'much as it is', so promoting him is unlikely to solve this problem. An external chef with experience of creating menus in larger restaurants could bring new ideas and modern dishes that win back customers. This matters because the restaurant earns about 40% of the hotel's revenue, so falling bookings have a big effect on the whole business. Using the cook-off, the owners can taste each applicant's food before appointing, which reduces the risk of choosing a chef who would damage the good food guide listing.
There are strong reasons to promote Owain. He has worked in the kitchen for six years, knows the suppliers and the menu, and is popular with the kitchen team, so the change would cause little disruption. He would cost £36 000 rather than £42 000, saving £6 000 a year, and his promotion would show other staff that they can progress. However, he has never run a kitchen on his own or controlled food costs, which could lower profit, and the hotel would still need to recruit a new sous chef.
Overall, recruiting externally is better because the hotel's biggest problem is competition from more modern restaurants, and this needs new ideas more than continuity. The extra £6 000 salary and £650 advert are small compared with the revenue the restaurant could win back. However, this depends on the new chef fitting in with the team, so the owners should try to keep Owain as sous chef, perhaps with a pay rise, so that his knowledge of the kitchen is not lost.