Item A
Glenmorie Kiltmakers Ltd
Glenmorie Kiltmakers Ltd is a family-owned company in Inverness. Each of its nine kiltmakers makes a kilt by hand from start to finish. The customer chooses from over 300 tartans and is measured in the shop, and the kiltmaker then cuts, pleats and hand-stitches the kilt to fit that customer exactly. Each kilt takes about 25 hours of work and sells for £650. Customers, many of whom are buying a kilt for a wedding, wait about ten weeks. Glenmorie's website and reviews stress that 'every kilt is made by one craftsperson, by hand'.
The kiltmakers are highly skilled: training a new kiltmaker takes about two years. They are proud of their work, and only one has left in the last five years.
Each summer thousands of tourists visit the shop. Many would like a kilt to take home but cannot wait ten weeks or pay £650. Fiona, the managing director, estimates that about 20 tourists a day ask for one. She is considering a ready-to-wear range in six standard sizes and 12 popular tartans, made using flow production. Machinists on a production line would each carry out one stage, such as cutting or machine-pleating. This would need:
- sewing and pressing machines costing £140 000, paid for with a bank loan
- six new machinists, as the kiltmakers' hand skills would not be used.
The ready-to-wear kilts would cost £90 each to make and sell for £195, and the line could make 150 kilts a week. Most tourists visit between April and October; in winter, Fiona thinks the kilts could be sold online. Two kiltmakers have warned that machine-made kilts sold under the Glenmorie name could damage its reputation.
Recommend whether Glenmorie Kiltmakers Ltd should introduce flow production for a ready-to-wear range of kilts. Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
Introducing flow production for a ready-to-wear range would let Glenmorie sell to a market it is currently losing. About 20 tourists a day ask for a kilt they can take home, but they cannot wait ten weeks or pay £650. A line making 150 kilts a week at a cost of £90 each could sell them for £195, a profit of £105 a kilt. About 1 334 kilts would earn enough to cover the £140 000 cost of the machines (£140 000 ÷ £105), which is roughly nine weeks of full output, and sales could continue online in winter. Because the made-to-measure kilts would still be made by hand, this extra revenue would not mean giving up the existing business.
However, there are real risks. Demand may not match output: 20 enquiries a day is about 140 a week, and not every tourist who asks will buy, so the line may often be idle, especially from November to March, while the bank loan must still be repaid with interest. The bigger risk is to Glenmorie's reputation. Its website and reviews stress that 'every kilt is made by one craftsperson, by hand', and that is why customers pay £650. If machine-made kilts are sold under the same name, wedding customers may feel the brand is less special and choose a rival kiltmaker, which would damage the more profitable part of the business. The kiltmakers are also unhappy, and they are hard to replace because training takes two years, so if they lose motivation or leave, the made-to-measure business would suffer.
I recommend that Glenmorie should introduce the ready-to-wear range, but sell it under a separate name so that the hand-made Glenmorie brand is protected. The tourist demand is real and the profit per kilt is high, so the machines could pay for themselves within one summer. Fiona should involve the kiltmakers in planning the range and reassure them that their jobs are safe. The decision depends on whether enough tourists actually buy at £195; if sales are slow, the loan becomes a burden.
Explanation
The top level weighs the new tourist market and low unit costs of flow production against the risks to the hand-made reputation, the loan and the kiltmakers' morale, using Glenmorie's figures. A strong conclusion makes a clear decision and says what it depends on, or how the risks could be reduced, for example by using a separate brand. Answers that compare job and flow production in general without the case evidence cannot reach Level 3.