Item D
Slitrig Knitwear Ltd
Slitrig Knitwear Ltd is a private limited company in Hawick in the Scottish Borders. It makes wool jumpers in two ranges. The Heritage range is knitted and then finished by hand by skilled staff, and sells for £140. The Basics range is plain jumpers knitted on machines, and sells to shops for £55. Every jumper carries a label saying 'Made in the Scottish Borders'. The business employs 46 staff.
Slitrig makes 1 500 Basics jumpers a month. Table 1 shows the monthly costs of making the Basics range in the business's own machine room.
The operations manager, Fiona, has been offered a contract by a knitwear factory in Leicester. The factory would make all of the Basics jumpers to Slitrig's design for £22 each, including delivery, with an order of at least 1 500 jumpers a month. If Slitrig outsources the Basics range, its fixed costs for the range would no longer be paid, and the machine room would become extra space for hand-finishing.
The eight machine operators would be offered retraining as hand-finishers. Fiona expects that three of them will choose redundancy instead. The Heritage range is very popular, and customers currently wait six weeks for an order because Slitrig does not have enough skilled hand-finishers.
The Leicester factory sent a sample of 50 Basics jumpers. Four had uneven stitching. Deliveries from Leicester would take five days, and the factory needs three weeks' notice to change the size of an order.
Recommend whether Slitrig Knitwear Ltd should outsource the production of its Basics range to the factory in Leicester. Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
Making a Basics jumper in-house costs Slitrig £26 on average: (£18 000 + £14 × 1 500) ÷ 1 500. The Leicester factory would charge £22 including delivery, so outsourcing would save £4 a jumper, or £6 000 a month (£72 000 a year) on 1 500 jumpers. This would increase the profit Slitrig makes on each £55 Basics jumper, so on cost alone outsourcing looks attractive.
Outsourcing could also help the Heritage range. Customers wait six weeks for a Heritage jumper because there are not enough skilled hand-finishers. If the machine room becomes hand-finishing space and five of the operators retrain, Slitrig could finish more £140 Heritage jumpers each month, reducing the waiting list and the risk that customers give up and buy elsewhere.
However, there are risks. Four of the 50 sample jumpers, 8%, had uneven stitching. Slitrig would no longer control quality, and if faulty jumpers reach shops the returns would cost money and damage Slitrig's reputation, which also supports its Heritage sales. The 'Made in the Scottish Borders' label would no longer be true for the Basics range, so it would have to change, and shops that buy from Slitrig because it is made locally might stop ordering. Supply would also be less flexible: the factory needs three weeks' notice to change an order, and Slitrig must take at least 1 500 jumpers a month even if demand falls. Three operators are likely to take redundancy, which costs money and may worry the remaining staff.
I recommend that Slitrig should outsource the Basics range, but only if the Leicester factory agrees to tighter quality standards and Slitrig checks each delivery when it arrives. The £72 000 a year saving and the chance to cut the six-week Heritage waiting list outweigh the risks, because each Heritage jumper earns far more than a Basics jumper. The decision depends on whether the stitching faults can be fixed and whether shops still buy the Basics range without the Borders label.
Explanation
A Level 3 answer uses the numbers (the £26 in-house cost against £22, and the 8% faulty sample) and the people issues (retraining, redundancy, the Heritage waiting list), then reaches a decision that says what it depends on. Answers that only describe outsourcing in general, or ignore the 'Made in the Scottish Borders' label and the quality risk, usually stay at Level 2.