Item C
Corrie Outdoor Adventures
Ewan and Shona run Corrie Outdoor Adventures, a partnership offering guided kayaking, canoeing and mountain-biking trips near Fort William in the Scottish Highlands. When they started three years ago they wrote a business plan to get a bank loan. The plan forecast 4 000 customers a year by the third year, but this year they had 2 600. Insurance costs have also risen faster than they expected. Even so, the business has made a small profit every year.
Most customers stay in hotels and holiday cottages, and many have asked whether Corrie offers accommodation. A former shooting lodge nearby, with 24 beds, is for sale for £260 000. The owner has offered to sell it to the partners if they agree within three weeks; otherwise it will be sold at auction in the spring. The partners could pay for it with £60 000 of their savings and a £200 000 loan from Ewan's parents, so they would not need a bank loan.
Running the lodge would mean employing a cook, two cleaners and at least four more instructors. Qualified instructors are hard to find in the area, and this summer Corrie had to cancel 30 trips when two instructors left. The partners work about 70 hours a week in the summer, but the business is much quieter in the autumn and winter. Shona thinks that updating the business plan properly would take at least a month.
Recommend whether Ewan and Shona should update their business plan before deciding whether to buy the lodge. Give reasons for your recommendation.
Model answer
Updating the business plan would reduce the risk of a very large decision. The lodge costs £260 000, paid with £60 000 of the partners' savings and £200 000 borrowed from Ewan's parents. Their first plan forecast 4 000 customers a year by now, but they actually had 2 600, 35% fewer, and insurance costs rose more than expected. If they are as optimistic about the lodge, they could find that bookings do not cover the costs of running it and repaying Ewan's parents. As a partnership they have unlimited liability, so their personal possessions could be at risk.
The plan would also force them to plan the staffing. The lodge needs a cook, two cleaners and at least four more instructors, but instructors are hard to find and this summer 30 trips were cancelled when two left. A staffing plan would show whether they can recruit enough people before opening, or whether the lodge would stretch the business too far.
On the other hand, Shona thinks a proper update would take at least a month, but the owner wants an answer within three weeks. If they miss this deadline, the lodge goes to auction, where other buyers may push the price up. They also do not need a bank loan, so nobody is insisting on a plan, and they already know from customers that there is demand for accommodation.
I recommend that they should update their plan before deciding, but keep it short and focused so it is done within three weeks. It is the quiet season, so they have time to concentrate on the most important parts: a realistic forecast of bookings and costs, a cash flow forecast for repaying Ewan's parents, and a staffing plan. The risk of losing their savings is greater than the risk of paying a little more at auction.
Explanation
Top answers weigh the benefits of planning (realistic forecasts, a staffing plan, protecting the partners' money) against its drawbacks (time and the three-week deadline) using evidence from Item C, such as the 35% shortfall against the first forecast. The recommendation must follow from this weighing and say what it depends on. Answers that only list advantages and disadvantages of business plans in general cannot go above Level 2.