Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/21

Organisational structures

Practise 28 exam-style questions on Organisational structures for AQA GCSE Business (Paper 1). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 28 questions
  • 1–12 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

A bank removes a whole level of area managers from its organisational structure.

What is this called?

Choose your answer.

  • Delegation
  • Delayering
  • Decentralisation
  • Centralisation

Model answer

Delayering

Explanation

Delayering means removing one or more levels of hierarchy, which makes the structure flatter and widens the spans of control of the managers who remain. Decentralisation is about who makes decisions, not how many levels there are, and delegation is passing authority to a subordinate. Students often confuse delayering with decentralisation because both can give junior staff more responsibility.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Delayering

    If more than one option is given, 0 marks.

Question 2

2 marks

Explain one drawback to a business of a wide span of control.

Model answer

With a wide span of control, a manager is responsible for many employees and has less time to supervise each of them. This means mistakes may not be noticed until it is too late, so the quality of work may fall.

Explanation

A wide span of control means one manager is responsible for many subordinates, so the drawback is usually less supervision, support or time for each person. The second mark needs the consequence for the business, such as falling quality or demotivated staff. Do not confuse a wide span with a tall structure, which has narrow spans.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Identifies a drawback: the manager has less time to supervise or support each employee / it is harder to monitor everyone's work / the manager may be overworked / there are more people to communicate with

    Max 2.

  2. 1 mark

    Explains the consequence: mistakes or poor quality may not be noticed / employees may feel unsupported and become demotivated / training needs may be missed / decisions may be slower because the manager is overloaded

    Examples of developed answers: The manager has less time to check each employee's work (1) so mistakes may not be spotted and quality may fall (1). The manager has many people to support (1) so employees may not get the help they need and become demotivated (1). Do not accept 'there are too many levels', which describes a tall structure.

Question 3

4 marks

Item A: Saltmarsh Brewing Co

Saltmarsh Brewing Co Ltd is a craft brewery near Whitby in North Yorkshire. It was started eight years ago by Nadia, who is now its managing director. It brews beer for pubs, shops and its own taproom, and employs 12 people. Figure 1 shows its organisational structure.

Until last year the head brewer was also responsible for packaging the beer into cans and bottles. As sales grew, cans were sometimes filled wrongly, labels were put on the wrong beers and deliveries to shops left late. Nadia created a new role of packaging supervisor, who reports to the head brewer. The packaging supervisor organises the four packers, plans the packaging schedule each week, checks the quality of every batch before it leaves the brewery and trains new packers.

Since the change, the number of batches returned by shops has fallen from 11 in 2024 to 2 in 2025. The head brewer now spends more time developing new beers, and two of Saltmarsh's new beers won awards this year. Nadia says that the packers are also more motivated, because they have one person to go to with problems instead of waiting for the head brewer, who is often busy in the brewhouse.

Explain one benefit to Saltmarsh Brewing Co of creating the role of packaging supervisor.

You should use the information in Item A in your answer.

Figure 1: Organisational structure of Saltmarsh Brewing Co. Block diagram with 12 parts in seven rows. Top row: a box "Managing director" (shaded). Third row, left to right: a box "Head brewer" and a box "Sales and admin manager" (wide). Fifth row, left to right: a box "Brewer", a box "Brewer", a box "Packaging supervisor", a box "Sales representative" and a box "Admin assistant". Bottom row, left to right: a box "Packer", a box "Packer", a box "Packer" and a box "Packer". Connections: a line joining "Managing director" and "Head brewer"; a line joining "Managing director" and "Sales and admin manager"; a line joining "Head brewer" and "Brewer" (fifth row, far left); a line joining "Head brewer" and "Brewer" (fifth row, 2nd from the left); a line joining "Head brewer" and "Packaging supervisor"; a line joining "Sales and admin manager" and "Sales representative"; a line joining "Sales and admin manager" and "Admin assistant"; a line joining "Packaging supervisor" and "Packer" (bottom row, far left); a line joining "Packaging supervisor" and "Packer" (bottom row, 2nd from the left); a line joining "Packaging supervisor" and "Packer" (bottom row, 2nd from the right); a line joining "Packaging supervisor" and "Packer" (bottom row, far right).

Model answer

A supervisor is responsible for organising and monitoring the day-to-day work of a team. At Saltmarsh, the packaging supervisor plans the packaging schedule and checks the quality of every batch before it leaves the brewery. Before the role was created, the head brewer was too busy in the brewhouse to check packaging properly, so cans were filled wrongly and labels were put on the wrong beers. Now one person is responsible for packaging quality, so mistakes are spotted before beer reaches the shops. This is why returned batches fell from 11 in 2024 to just 2 in 2025, which saves Saltmarsh the cost of replacing faulty beer and protects its reputation with the shops it supplies.

Explanation

Level 2 needs an understanding of what a supervisor does or how the new level changes the structure, applied with evidence from Item A such as the fall in returned batches or the head brewer's extra time for new beers. Explain one benefit fully rather than listing several. A general answer about supervisors, without Saltmarsh's details, stays in Level 1.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO1 = 2, AO2 = 2.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Sound understanding and application of the topics. Applies knowledge and understanding to the context sufficiently. A sound understanding of one or more business concepts and issues.
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Basic understanding and application of the topics. Applies basic knowledge and understanding to the context. A basic understanding of one or more business concepts.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Knowledge: a supervisor is responsible for organising, monitoring and supporting the day-to-day work of a team; adding the role gives one person clear responsibility for packaging and narrows the head brewer's span of control. Application: the packaging supervisor organises the four packers, plans the packaging schedule each week, checks the quality of every batch and trains new packers; before the change cans were filled wrongly, labels were put on the wrong beers and deliveries left late; returned batches fell from 11 in 2024 to 2 in 2025; the head brewer now spends more time developing new beers, and two new beers won awards; packers have one person to go to with problems, so they are more motivated. Example of a Level 2 answer: A supervisor organises and checks the work of a team. Saltmarsh's packaging supervisor checks the quality of every batch before it leaves the brewery, so mistakes such as wrong labels are found before beer reaches shops. This is why returned batches fell from 11 to 2, which saves the cost of replacing faulty beer and protects Saltmarsh's reputation. An answer not applied to Saltmarsh cannot go above Level 1. Level 2 needs a correct understanding of the role or of the change to the structure, applied to Saltmarsh with some explanation of the benefit.

Question 4

9 marks

Item B: Haughmond Logistics Ltd

Haughmond Logistics Ltd runs a large warehouse near Doncaster that stores and packs goods for online retailers. The warehouse works three eight-hour shifts a day, seven days a week, and employs 121 people. Table 1 shows the warehouse staff.

Each shift manager is responsible for one shift and manages three supervisors. Each supervisor manages a team of twelve warehouse operatives, checks their work, deals with problems such as damaged stock and trains new operatives. Many of the supervisors were promoted from operative roles, and several operatives say they hope to become supervisors.

Competition from other warehouses has forced Haughmond to cut its prices, and its profit has fallen for two years. The operations director, Mark, wants to delayer by removing the supervisor level. All nine supervisors would be made redundant, at a one-off cost of £58 000, and the three shift managers would each be paid an extra £4 000 a year for managing their operatives directly.

Mark points out that every operative now uses a handheld scanner that records each item picked, so shift managers can see errors on a screen straight away. However, the warehouse uses forklift trucks, and Haughmond's health and safety manager is worried that shift managers will not be able to watch over so many operatives. Haughmond's error rate in picking orders is 0.4%, one of the lowest in the industry, and its largest customer has said that accuracy is the main reason it uses Haughmond.

Recommend whether Haughmond Logistics should remove the supervisor level.

Give reasons for your recommendation.

Table 1: Warehouse staff at Haughmond Logistics Ltd. Table with columns "Job role", "Number of staff", "Salary per person (£ per year)". Job role: Warehouse manager; Number of staff: 1; Salary per person (£ per year): 54 000 | Job role: Shift manager; Number of staff: 3; Salary per person (£ per year): 39 000 | Job role: Supervisor; Number of staff: 9; Salary per person (£ per year): 31 000 | Job role: Warehouse operative; Number of staff: 108; Salary per person (£ per year): 24 500.

Model answer

I recommend that Haughmond does not remove the whole supervisor level, but reduces the number of supervisors instead.

Removing the supervisor level would save Haughmond a large amount of money. The nine supervisors earn £31 000 each, so after paying the three shift managers an extra £4 000 each, salary costs would fall by £267 000 a year. The one-off redundancy cost of £58 000 would be covered within the first year. As Haughmond's profit has fallen for two years because competitors have forced it to cut its prices, this saving would help it to compete. Removing a level would also shorten the chain of command, so instructions from the warehouse manager would reach operatives faster, and the handheld scanners mean shift managers can see picking errors on screen straight away.

However, the change would give each shift manager a span of control of 36 operatives instead of 3 supervisors. That is very wide, and supervisors do much more than check errors: they deal with damaged stock, train new operatives and watch over safety in a warehouse with forklift trucks. With 36 people each, shift managers could not do all of this, so accidents and mistakes could increase. Accuracy matters a great deal to Haughmond, because its error rate of 0.4% is one of the lowest in the industry and its largest customer says accuracy is the main reason it uses Haughmond. If errors rose, Haughmond could lose this customer, and the lost revenue could be far greater than £267 000. Removing supervisors would also end the main promotion route for operatives, which could demotivate them and increase staff turnover.

The decision depends on whether the scanners can really replace the supervision that supervisors give. Because accuracy and safety are so important to Haughmond, the risk of removing the whole level is too high. A better option would be to keep fewer supervisors with larger teams, for example six supervisors with eighteen operatives each, which would still save money while keeping supervision, training and a route for promotion.

Explanation

Top answers weigh the £267 000 yearly saving against the risks to accuracy, safety and motivation, using evidence such as the span of control rising to 36 and the largest customer's focus on accuracy. A strong conclusion says what the decision depends on and may suggest a compromise. Answers that only describe delayering in general, without Haughmond's figures, stay in Level 2.

Mark scheme
  1. 9 marks

    Levels of response (9 marks). AO2 = 3, AO3 = 6.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Detailed analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. Sustained line of reasoning, which is coherent, relevant, substantiated with a focused conclusion that is fully justified. Business areas are fully analysed. Applies knowledge and understanding to the context sufficiently.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Sound analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. A line of reasoning, with a conclusion that has some justification. Business areas are partially analysed. Applies some knowledge and understanding to the context.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic analysis and evaluation of topics based on the context. Basic line of reasoning with a conclusion. Basic analysis of business areas. Basic knowledge and understanding is applied to the context.
    0 marks: nothing to reward.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Application and analysis - for removing the supervisor level: removing nine supervisors at £31 000 each and paying three shift managers an extra £4 000 each saves £267 000 a year; the one-off redundancy cost of £58 000 is covered in the first year (net first-year saving £209 000); profit has fallen for two years because competitors have forced Haughmond to cut prices, so lower costs would help it compete; delayering shortens the chain of command (warehouse manager, shift manager, operative), so instructions reach operatives faster and decisions are quicker; handheld scanners record every item picked, so shift managers can see errors on screen straight away. Against: each shift manager's span of control would rise from 3 supervisors to 36 operatives, which is very wide; supervisors check work, deal with damaged stock and train new operatives, so these tasks may not be done well; forklift trucks make supervision important for health and safety, and the health and safety manager is worried; the error rate of 0.4% is one of the lowest in the industry and the largest customer uses Haughmond mainly for accuracy, so more errors could lose this customer and far more revenue than £267 000; the supervisor role is the main promotion route for operatives, so removing it could demotivate operatives and increase staff turnover; redundancies may lower morale. Evaluation - what does it depend on? Whether the scanners can replace the checking that supervisors do; whether shift managers can cope with 36 operatives; how important the largest customer is to Haughmond's revenue; whether a compromise is possible, such as fewer supervisors with larger teams, or team leaders on lower pay. Accept any well-justified recommendation. Level 3 needs a sustained line of reasoning using the case and a fully justified conclusion. A generic answer that does not use the case cannot go above Level 2, however well developed.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.