Question 1
3 marksA student photographed a tardigrade (water bear), a tiny invertebrate, through an optical microscope. In the photograph, the tardigrade is 51 mm long. The magnification of the photograph is × 150.
Calculate the actual length of the tardigrade. Give your answer in μm.
The teacher then made an enlarged copy of the photograph on a photocopier. Another student measured the length of the tardigrade on the enlarged copy and divided it by 150. Explain how this would affect the actual length that the second student calculated.
Model answer
Image length = 51 mm = 51 × 1000 = 51 000 μm
Actual length = image size ÷ magnification = 51 000 ÷ 150 = 340 μm
The second student's length would be too large. Enlarging the photograph makes the image of the tardigrade longer, so the magnification of the copy is greater than × 150; dividing the longer image length by 150 gives an actual length larger than the true length.
Explanation
Magnification = image size ÷ actual size, so actual size = image size ÷ magnification, with both lengths in the same unit: convert the image length to μm first (1 mm = 1000 μm), then divide. A stated magnification applies only to the image it was worked out for: enlarging or reducing a photograph changes its magnification, so dividing by the original value gives a wrong actual size (a scale bar avoids this, because it is enlarged with the image). Multiplying by the magnification instead of dividing is a common error.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
Correct method: 51 000 ÷ 150 (image length in μm divided by magnification); or a correct final answer of 340 μm with no working
A correct answer of 340 μm with no working scores 2 marks (points 1 and 2). Accept for 1 mark: 0.34 (correct length in mm, not converted to μm) OR evidence of 51 000 μm. Do not award for 7650 (51 × 150) or 2.9 (150 ÷ 51).
-
1 mark
340 (μm)
-
1 mark
The calculated length would be too large / an overestimate, because the enlarged copy has a greater magnification than × 150 (the image is longer but the same magnification was used)
Both the effect (too large) and the reason are needed. Accept 'the magnification of the copy is × 150 multiplied by the enlargement, so dividing by 150 gives too large a length'. Reject 'too small'. Ignore 'it would be inaccurate' or 'it would be wrong' with no direction.