Marta investigates how the pressure of a fixed mass of air depends on its temperature. The air is in a sealed glass flask, which is joined to a pressure gauge by a long rubber tube. She stands the flask in a beaker of water, heats the water, and records the temperature of the water and the reading on the pressure gauge.
Only the bottom half of the flask is under the water.
Her teacher says that, when the water is hot, the pressure readings will be lower than they should be for the temperature of the water.
Explain why the teacher is right, and suggest two improvements to Marta's method.
Model answer
The top half of the flask and the long tube are not in the hot water, so the air in them is cooler than the water. The particles in this cooler air move more slowly, so on average the air particles hit the walls less often and with less force than they would if all of the air were at the temperature of the water. So the pressure reading is lower than it should be.
Improvements: put the whole flask under the water, for example by using a deeper beaker, and use a much shorter tube between the flask and the gauge.
Explanation
For the results to show how the pressure depends on the temperature of the water, all of the air must be at that temperature. Air outside the water bath stays cooler, so its particles move more slowly and the pressure is too low. Good improvements deal with this, for example by covering the flask completely, keeping the tube short, stirring the water and waiting for the reading to settle.