Poor harvests in several of the world's main orange-growing regions, caused by bad weather and a disease that damages orange trees, have pushed up the world price of oranges.
Figure 1 shows data for Brightwell Juices, a UK maker of orange juice (invented data).
Using Figure 1, analyse the possible effects of the rise in the price of oranges on the supply of orange juice by firms such as Brightwell Juices.
Model answer
Oranges are the main raw material in orange juice, so a rise in their price raises the cost of producing every carton. Figure 1 shows that the price Brightwell Juices paid for oranges tripled from £400 to £1 200 a tonne, and oranges rose from 25% to 50% of the cost of making a carton. If its other costs did not change, this means each carton costs about 50% more to make.
With higher costs, each carton is less profitable at any given price, so juice makers are willing to supply fewer cartons at every price. The supply curve of orange juice shifts to the left: this is a decrease in supply, not a movement along the curve, because the cause is a cost of production, not the price of orange juice itself.
Some firms may respond by changing what they supply. They might sell smaller cartons, make juice drinks that contain less orange, or switch some production to blends with cheaper fruit such as apple, so the supply of pure orange juice falls further. Smaller juice makers with thin profit margins may not be able to cover their costs at all and could leave the market, reducing market supply again.
The effect may not be immediate. Firms that agreed contracts with growers or bought orange concentrate months in advance may keep supplying at first and cut back only when their cheaper stocks run out. The bigger the share of costs that oranges make up, the larger the leftward shift in supply will be, and Brightwell's figures show that this share has doubled.
Explanation
Top answers use the figure (the price paid tripled; oranges' share of costs rose from 25% to 50%) and build a chain: higher input costs, lower profit per carton at each price, less supplied at every price, a leftward shift of supply. Further development such as smaller cartons, cheaper blends, firms leaving the market, or stocks bought in advance reaches Level 3. Treating the change as a movement along the supply curve is a serious error.