Country X is a major grower of avocados. Avocado trees take about four years after planting to produce fruit. In Year 2, demand for avocados from Country X rose sharply as they became more popular in Europe, and many growers planted new trees. Most growers are small family farms, and planting and watering new trees is expensive. Figure 1 shows the price paid to growers and the quantity of avocados supplied from Year 1 to Year 6 (invented data).
Using Figure 1, assess whether the increase in demand for avocados has benefited growers in Country X.
Model answer
In the short run the increase in demand clearly benefited existing growers. Because avocado trees take about four years to produce fruit, supply was very price inelastic: between Year 1 and Year 2 the price rose by 60%, from 1.50 to 2.40 US dollars per kg, but the quantity supplied rose by only 5%, from 80 to 84 thousand tonnes, giving a PES of about 0.08. As a result growers' total revenue rose from about 120 million US dollars (80,000 tonnes × 1.50 per kg) to about 201.6 million in Year 2 and 228.8 million in Year 3. Growers who already had trees gained most, because their costs hardly changed while the price of what they sold rose sharply, so their profits rose. The higher price also acted as a signal and an incentive to expand production.
However, the benefits did not last. Many growers planted new trees, which cost money for land, water and labour but earned nothing for about four years. When the new trees began to produce fruit from Year 4, supply shifted to the right: quantity rose to 140 thousand tonnes in Year 6 while the price fell to 1.40 US dollars per kg, below its Year 1 level. Total revenue fell to about 196 million US dollars in Year 6. That is still higher than in Year 1, but it is now shared among more growers, and with more trees to look after, total costs are much higher. So profit per grower, especially for those who planted late and borrowed to do so, may be lower than before demand rose.
Overall, the increase in demand benefited growers in Country X in the short run, because inelastic supply meant the extra demand raised prices rather than quantity. In the long run the benefit is much less clear, because the growers' own response increased supply and pushed the price down. Whether growers have gained overall depends on when they planted, on their costs (especially water and loans) and on whether demand in Europe keeps rising; if it does, the lower price in Year 6 may only be temporary.
Explanation
Strong answers use Figure 1 to show that supply was price inelastic at first (a 60% price rise with a 5% rise in quantity) and calculate revenue, then explain how the lagged supply response pushed the price down later. Level 3 needs a judgement that distinguishes the short run from the long run and says what the answer depends on. Answers that use no data, or consider only the benefits, cannot score more than 6.